Accreditation of the activities of ministers as a mechanism for counteracting religious extremist ideology: friends amidst foes or foes amidst friends?

Available in Russian

Price 180 Rub.

Author: Igor Pibaev

DOI: 10.21128/1812-7126-2022-1-108-135

Keywords: clergy; imams; islam; accreditation; autonomy; religious organizations; European Union; extremism


The tendency that has emerged in Russia over the past years towards strengthening control over the regulation of activities of religious associations has led to significant changes in the regulation of freedom of religion by creating mechanisms (sets of requirements) intended to prevent the spread of religious extremist ideology by clerics. The author examines the accreditation of clergy by public authorities in two different aspects: local and cross-border. An attempt is made to compare Russian and foreign innovations aimed at protecting national security. The second section of the article analyzes the Russian experience of local accreditation. The third section focuses on the experience of countries with the largest percentage of Islamic populations – France, Germany and Bulgaria. In the fourth section, special attention is paid to the study of the legislation and practice of those states (Turkey, Algeria, Egypt) that send Islamic clerics abroad or provide an opportunity for them to receive religious education. As a result, the author, having considered a wide range of methods of accreditation of the religious activities of clergy, formulates optimal mechanisms for reducing negative foreign influence in the religious sphere and for satisfying Muslims’ needs for trained Imams.

About the author: Igor Pibaev – Candidate of Sciences (Ph.D.) in Law, Associate Professor, Department of State Legal Disciplines, Volga-Vyatka Institute (branch) of the Moscow State University of Law named after O. E. Kutafin (MSAL), Kirov, Russia.

Citation: Pibaev I. (2022) Akkreditatsiya deyatel'nosti svyashchennosluzhiteley kak mekhanizm protivodeystviya religiozno-ekstremistskoy ideologii: svoi sredi chuzhikh ili chuzhie sredi svoikh? [Accreditation of the activities of ministers as a mechanism for counteracting religious extremist ideology: friends amidst foes or foes amidst friends?]. Sravnitel'noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie, vol. 31, no. 1, pp. 108–135. (In Russian).


Aminov T.M. (2017). Sistema islamskogo obrazovaniya Duhovnogo upravleniya musul'man Res­publiki Bashkortostan na sovremennom etape [The system of Islamic education of the spiritual administration of Muslims of the Republic of Bashkortostan at the present stage]. Pedagogiche­skiy zhurnal Bashkortostana, no. 3, pp. 78–87. (In Russian).

Arkilic Z.A. (2015) The Limits of European Islam: Turkish Islamic Umbrella Organizations and Their Relations with Host Countries – France and Germany. Journal of Muslim Minority Affairs, vol. 35, no. 1, pp. 17–42.

Aslan E., Windisch Z. (eds.) (2012) The Training of Imams and Teachers for Islamic Education in Europe, Frankfurt am Main: Peter Lang.

Barakat I. (2018) Al-Azhar’s Role in Freedom of Belief in Egypt. The Tahrir Institute for Middle East Policy, 12 July. Available at: (accessed: 28.01.2022).

Boender W. (2021) Professionalizing the Imam in Europe: Imam Training Programs as Sites of Deliberative Engagement. Religions, vol. 12, no. 5.

Breyton R. (2019) Deutschpflicht für Imame? “Das löst nicht das Problem”. Welt, 8 November. Available at: (accessed: 28.01.2022).

Bruce B. (2019) Governing Islam Abroad: Turkish and Moroccan Muslims in Western Europe, Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.

Buyruk H. (2021) The Role of Religious Education in Hegemony Construction: The Case of Imam Hatip Schools in Turkey. Paedagogica Historica, vol. 57, no. 6, pp. 657–674.

Fahmi G. (2014) The Egyptian State and the Religious Sphere. Malcolm H. Kerr Carnegie Middle East Center, 18 September. Available at: (accessed: 28.01.2022).

Fedele V. (2016) Training Imams of France: A Socio-Islamological Approach. Oriente Moderno, vol. 96, no. 2, pp. 211–229.

Gürlesin Ö.F. (2019) Major Socio-Political Factors that Impact on the Changing Role, Perception and Image of Imams among Dutch-Turkish Muslims. Education Sciences, vol. 9, no. 3, pp. 1–14.

Hashas M., de Ruiter J.J., Vinding N.V. (eds.) (2018) Imams in Western Europe: Developments, Transformations, and Institutional Challenges, Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press.

Keeble E. (2014) The Cross-Cultural Roundtable on Security as a Response to Radicalization: Personal Experiences and Academic Reflections. In: Bramadat P., Dawson L.L. (eds.) Religious Radicalization and Securization in Canada and Beyond, Toronto: University of Toronto Press, pp. 259–284.

Kochoi S.M. (2021) Ugolovno-pravovoe protivodeystvie ideologicheskomu ekstremizmu [Criminal law counteraction to ideological extremism]. Zhurnal rossiyskogo prava, no. 11, pp. 117–132. (In Russian).

Motilla A. (2018) Security and Religious Radicalization. Securitization of Islam in Europe. Stato, Chiese e pluralismo confessionale, no. 1, pp. 1–20.

Noweira A. (2016) The Reformation of Official Religious Institutions in Tunisia, Egypt, and Yemen. Arab Forum for Alternatives. Available at: (accessed: 28.01.2022).

Öztürk A.E., Sözeri S. (2018) Diyanet as a Turkish Foreign Policy Tool: Evidence from the Netherlands and Bulgaria. Politics and Religion, vol. 11, no. 3, pp. 624–648.

Ponkin I.V. (2003) Pravovye osnovy svetskosti gosudarstva i obrazovaniya [Legal foundations of the secular state and education], Moscow: Pro-Press. (In Russian).

Popov R. (2013) Islam in Modern Bulgaria: 1878 to Present Days. Occasional Papers on Religion in Eastern Europe, vol. 33, no. 2, pp. 1–6.

Preljević H., Ljubović M. (2021) Re-thinking About Muslim Migration into the European Union. Journal of Muslim Minority Affairs, vol. 41, no. 2, pp. 263–280.

Rohe M. (2008) Islamic Norms in Germany and Europe. In: Al-Hamarneh A., Thielmann J. (eds.) Islam and Muslims in Germany, Leiden; Boston, MA: Brill, pp. 49–81.

Röther Ch. (2019) Sprachkenntnisse ausländischer Geistlicher. Deutschlandfunk, 12. März. Available at: (accessed: 28.01.2022).

Ryabykh F., Ponkin I.V., Ponkina A.I. (2012) O priznanii isklyuchitel'noy kompetentsii religioznykh organizatsiy po ustanovleniyu ikh vnutrenney struktury i vnutrennikh norm otnosheniy kak odnoy iz garantiy svobody veroisovedaniya v demokraticheskom gosudarstve [On the recognition of the exclusive competence of religious organizations to establish their internal structure and internal norms of relations as one of the guarantees of freedom of religion in a democratic state]. Nrav­stvennye imperativy v prave, no. 3, pp. 11–32. (In Russian).

Şahin I., Kesik F. (2019) A Critical Review of Religious Education Policies and Practices of Turkey from the Perspective of Inclusion. Education as Change, vol. 23, no. 1, pp. 1–22.

Salkina М. (2016) Institutsionalizatsiya islama vo Frantsii. Ot etnicheskogo lobbizma k konfessional'nomu? [Institutionalization of Islam in France. A path from ethnic to religious lobbying?]. Mezhdunarodnye protsessy, no. 2, pp. 112–122. (In Russian).

Schmid H. (2020) “I’m just an Imam, not Superman”: Imams in Switzerland. Journal of Muslims in Europe, vol. 9, no. 1, pp. 64–95.

Scott R.M. (2021) Recasting Islamic Law: Religion and the Nation State in Egyptian Constitution Making, Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.

Sèze R. (2019) Prévenir la violence djihadiste: les paradoxes d’un modèle sécuritaire, Paris: Seuil.

Shakhov M.O., Pchelintsev A.V., Zagrebina I.V. (2017) Vnutrennie ustanovleniya religioznikh ob'edineniy [Internal regulations of religious associations], Moscow: Religioznaya organizatsiya Obrazovatel'naya organizatsiya vysshego obrazovaniya Moskovskiy teologicheskiy institut khri­stian very evangel'skoy. (In Russian).

Silant'ev R.A. (2014) Spetsifika privlecheniya k ugolovnoy otvetstvennosti musul'manskikh duhovnykh lits Rossii v noveyshiy period [The specifics of criminal prosecution of Muslim clerics in Russia in the recent period]. Musul'manskiy mir, no. 2, pp. 80–84. (In Russian).

Van Bruinessen M. (2018) The Governance of Islam in Two Secular Polities: Turkey’s Diyanet and Indonesia’s Ministry of Religious Affairs. European Journal of Turkish Studies. Available at: (accessed: 28.01.2022).

Yildirim M. (2011) The Diyanet – The Elephant in Turkey’s Religious Freedom Room?, 4 May. Available at: (accessed: 28.01.2022).

Yildirim M. (2020) Are Turkey’s Restrictions on Freedom of Religion or Belief Permissible? Religion and Human Rights, vol. 15, no. 1–2, pp. 172–191.

Yükleyen A., Yurdakul G. (2011) Islamic Activism and Immigrant Integration: Turkish Organizations in Germany. Immigrants & Minorities, vol. 29, no. 1, pp. 64–85.

Yunusova A.B. (2016) Imamy – slaboe zveno rossiyskogo islama (k voprosu o resursakh dukhov­noy bezopasnosti) [Imams are a weak link in Russian Islam (to the question of spiritual security resources)]. Ekonomika i upravlenie, no. 5, pp. 93–100. (In Russian).