Available in Russian
Author: Nikita Fedotov
DOI: 10.21128/1812-7126-2024-1-40-59
Keywords: telemedicine technologies; medical devices; medical applications; pseudonymization; anonymization; medical confidentiality; personal data; confidential information
The article discusses the issue of medical confidentiality arising from telemedicine technologies, medical devices, and medical applications. With digitalization, use of these technologies, devices and applications is associated with the risk of leakage of personal data, breach of medical confidentiality, and disclosure of confidential patient information. It is important to ensure that these risks are mitigated to protect patient privacy and confidentiality. The study examines the legal nature of medical confidentiality, its relationship with other types of secrets, and the reasons why it must be respected. To investigate medical confidentiality, the author also examined the problem of citizens’ inability to access anonymous paid medical services when using telemedicine technologies. The author concluded that complete anonymity cannot be guaranteed, but pseudonymization of patient data can protect the right to anonymous receipt of paid medical services. The article reviews the use of telemedicine technologies by doctors and highlights the risk of disclosure of medical confidentiality when third-party communication applications are used. Statistical data shows that patients’ medical data is compromised in such cases. The article uses formal-legal and comparative methods, analysis, deduction, and induction, to reach its conclusions and to make recommendations. In order to find a solution to the issue of observing medical confidentiality when using medical applications for remote monitoring of a patient’s health status, Russian legislation was compared with foreign legislation as applied. This comparison reveals that Russian legislation does not fully regulate the use of medical applications in this area. Amendments to Russian legislation, based on German and European Union legislation, are proposed. Additionally, a regulatory legal act should be developed to define measures for protecting patients’ confidential information when medical devices and applications are used.
About the author: Nikita Fedotov – Ph.D. Student, Faculty of Law, Lomonosov Moscow State University, Moscow, Russia.
Citation: Fedotov N. (2024) Otdel’nye aspekty zashchity vrachebnoy tayny pri ispol’zovanii telemeditsinskikh tekhnologiy v zdravookhranenii [Aspects of medical confidentiality protection in the use of telemedicine technology in healthcare]. Sravnitel’noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie, vol. 33, no. 1, pp. 40–59. (In Russian).
References
Akulin I.M., Chesnokova E.A., Smirnova K.M., Presnyakov R.A. (2019) Transformatsiya instituta vrachebnoy tayny v epokhu elektronnogo zdravookhraneniya [Transformation of the institution of medical confidentiality in the era of e-health]. Zakon, no.9, pp.179–189. (In Russian).
Barkhatova E.Yu. (2020) Kommentariy k Konstitutsii Rossiyskoy Federatsii: novaya redaktsiya (postateynyy) [Commentary on the Constitution of the Russian Federation: new edition (article-by-article)], 3rd ed., Moscow: Prospekt. (In Russian).
Blinov S.V., Kuz'mina N.M., Revina S.N., Sidorova A.V. (2019) Soblyudenie vrachebnoy tayny pri okazanii telemeditsinskikh uslug [Compliance with medical confidentiality when providing telemedicine services]. Vestnik meditsinskogo instituta “Reaviz”: reabilitatsiya, vrach i zdorov'e, no.2, pp.196–200. (In Russian).
Boyko I.B., Buzina O.I. (2021) O vrachebnoy tayne i ee soblyudenii v Federal'nom zakone ot 21 noyabrya 2011 g. Nº323-FZ “Ob osnovakh okhrany zdorov'ya grazhdan v Rossiyskoy Federatsii” [On medical confidentiality and its observance in the Federal Law of November 21, 2011 no.323-FZ “On the fundamentals of protecting the health of citizens in the Russian Federation”]. Meditsinskoe pravo, no.3, pp.37–42. (In Russian).
Bratanovskiy S.N. (2022) Pravovoy rezhim konfidentsial'noy informatsii: ponyatie i vidy [Legal regime of confidential information: concept and types]. Vektor nauki Tol'yattinskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriya: Yuridicheskie nauki, no.1, pp.30–34. (In Russian).
Bulanova V.S. (2021) Pravovoe obespechenie telemeditsinskikh uslug i tsifrovaya transformatsiya: teoretiko-metodologicheskie voprosy [Legal support of telemedicine services and digital transformation: theoretical and methodological issues]. Monitoring pravoprimeneniya, no.2, pp.59–64. (In Russian).
Chayka V.K., Vustenko V.V., Morozova N.A. (2022) O riskakh tsifrovizatsii zdravookhraneniya [Some risks of digitalization of healthcare]. Mediko-sotsial'nye problemy sem'i, no.4, pp.64–74. (In Russian).
Esayas S.Y. (2015) The Role of Anonymisation and Pseudonymisation under the EU Data Privacy Rules: Beyond the “All or Nothing” Approach. European Journal of Law and Technology, vol.6, no.2. Available at: https://ejlt.org/index.php/ejlt/article/view/378/569 (accessed: 08.03.2024).
Fat'yanov A.A. (1997) Problemy zashchity konfidentsial'noy informatsii, ne sostavlyayushchey gosudarstvennuyu taynu [Problems of protection of confidential information that does not constitute a state secret]. Informatsionnoe obshchestvo, no.1, pp.49–56. (In Russian).
Gallese N.C. (2023) Legal Aspects of the Use Artificial Intelligence in Telemedicine. Journal of Digital Technologies and Law, vol.1, no.2, pp.314–336.
Kartskhiya A.A. (2021) Informatsionno-pravovoe obespechenie tsifrovoy ekosistemy zdravookhraneniya [Legal information support for a digital health ecosystem]. Pravovaya informatika, no.1, pp.13–23. (In Russian).
Kryukova E.S. (2021) Vrachebnaya tayna v aspekte okhrany geneticheskoy informatsii [Medical confidentiality in the aspect of protection of genetic information]. Pravovoe gosudarstvo: teoriya i praktika, no.2, pp.11–25. (In Russian).
Kovalevskiy M.A., Akulin I.M., Kovalevskaya N.S. (2016) Institut yuridicheskoy zashchity svedeniy o patsiente (vrachebnoy tayny): istoriya stanovleniya i konstitutsionno-pravovoy rezhim (v aspekte semeynykh otnosheniy) [Institute of legal protection of data on the patient (medical confidentiality): history of formation and a constitutional-legal regime (in the aspect of family relations)]. Obyazatel'noe meditsinskoe strakhovanie v Rossiyskoy Federatsii, no.1, pp.58–73. (In Russian).
Lapina M.A. (2022) Organizatsionno-pravovye i finansovye aspekty tsifrovizatsii i vnedreniya tekhnologiy iskusstvennogo intellekta v oblasti zdravookhraneniya [Organizational, legal and financial aspects of digitalization and implementation of artificial intelligence technologies in healthcare]. Finansy: teoriya i praktika, no.3, pp.169–185. (In Russian).
Popova A.V. (2019) Telemeditsina v Rossii i za rubezhom: k voprosu o pravovom regulirovanii [Telemedicine in Russia and abroad, on the issue of legal regulation]. Vestnik Moskovskogo gosudarstvennogo pedagogicheskogo universiteta. Seriya: Yuridicheskie nauki, no.1, pp.53–60. (In Russian).
Serebryakov A.A. (2020) Dopustimost' predostavleniya svedeniy, sostavlyayushchikh vrachebnuyu taynu, v publichnykh interesakh [Admissibility of providing information constituting medical confidentiality in the public interest]. Rossiysko-aziatskiy pravovoy zhurnal, no.1, pp.28–32. (In Russian).
Stolbov A.P. (2015) Ob opredelenii i klassifikatsii telemeditsinskikh uslug [On the definition and classification of telemedicine services]. Vrach i informatsionnye tekhnologii, no.2, pp.12–28. (In Russian).
Shaydullina V.K. (2018) Problemy pravovogo regulirovaniya telemeditsiny v usloviyakh tsifrovoy ekonomiki. Obshchestvo: politika, ekonomika, pravo, no.8, pp.92–96. (In Russian).
Voronkova S.V. (2022) Pravovoe regulirovanie elektronnogo zdravookhraneniya trudnodostupnykh territoriy [Legal regulation of e-health in remote territories]. In: Begisheva I.R. et al. (eds.) Tsifrovye tekhnologii i pravo: sbornik nauchnykh trudov I Mezhdunarodnoy nauchno-prakticheskoy konferentsii, Kazan', 23 September 2022 goda. Tom 3 [Digital technologies and law: collection of scientific articles of the I International Scientific and Practical Conference (Kazan, September 23, 2022). Vol.3], in 6 vols., Kazan: Poznanie, pp.217–226. (In Russian).
Yakovets E.N. (2014) Svoeobrazie sostava zashchishchaemoy konfidentsial'noy informatsii [The originality of the composition of the protected confidential information]. Pravo i kiberbezopasnost', no.2, pp.51–58. (In Russian).
Zhuravlev M.S. (2017) Pravovoe obespechenie elektronnogo dokumentooborota v telemeditsine [Legal support of electronic document management in telemedicine]. Informatsionnoe pravo, no.4, pp.10–15. (In Russian).
Zhuravlev M.S. (2021) Pravovye aspekty informatsionnoy bezopasnosti v telemeditsine: Avtoref. dis. … kand. yurid. nauk [Legal aspects of information security in telemedicine: Abstract of a dissertation … candidate of legal science], Мoscow. (In Russian).