
Available in Russian
Author: Igor Kravets
DOI: 10.21128/1812-7126-2024-1-60-89
Keywords: humanism; democratic constitutionalism; algorithmic society; self-determination of the people; digital constitutionalism; interactive constitution; popular sovereignty; deliberative participation; citizen assemblies; involvement; democratic constitutional crowdsourcing
The article discusses the theoretical foundations and applied aspects of democratic constitutionalism; democratic constitutional crowdsourcing and constitutional inclusion in the information and algorithmic society; and the relationship between digital constitutionalism and popular sovereignty, on the one hand, and digital sovereignty and citizen participation, on the other hand. The author discusses scholarly approaches to understanding models of digital constitutionalism in the context of the international debate in comparative constitutional discourse and jurisprudence, as well as the prospects for self-determination of the people in analogue and digital forms of constitutionalism. The study provides a critical analysis of democratic constitutionalism from the perspectives of deliberative participation and digital engagement, various versions of popular constitutionalism, and their relationship with the cult of the written constitution and with judicial review of constitutional laws. It notes that the voice of the people in modern constitutionalism, based primarily on the cult of a written constitution, was not immediately heard, although the appeal to popular sovereignty as a constitutional principle of democratic states is a distinctive feature of popular constitutions. The author analyzes the idea of popular assemblies in modern constitutional theory, which has changed under the influence of digital and information technologies. These citizens’ assemblies are not intended to replace representative government, which itself needs preservation and modernization. Rather, their role is to fulfill the subsidiary but extremely important function of direct citizen participation in discussion and decision-making on publicly significant issues. The article analyzes models of digital constitutionalism in modern Russian and international jurisprudence and in scholarly publications. It covers the prospects for creating intellectual and normative foundations for interactive constitutions and electronic legislation, an international bill of rights on the Internet, legal recognition of information interests and needs, and opportunities for using constitutional crowdsourcing technology to discuss existing constitutional norms and create a new constitution. The article used deliberative and epistemological approaches, methods of formal-legal, concrete-historical, comparative constitutional-legal and complex analysis.
About the author: Igor Kravets – Doctor of Sciences in Law, Professor, Acting Head of the Department of Constitutional and Municipal Law, Chief Researcher at the Institute for the Philosophy and Law, Novosibirsk State University, Novosibirsk, Russia.
Citation: Kravets I. (2024) Demokraticheskiy konstitutsionnyy kraudsorsing i modeli tsifrovogo konstitutsionalizma dlya publichno-pravovoy kommunikatsii i konstitutsionnykh izmeneniy [Democratic constitutional crowdsourcing and models of digital constitutionalism for public legal communication and constitutional changes]. Sravnitel’noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie, vol. 33, no. 1, pp. 60–89. (In Russian).
References
Abat i Ninet A. (2021) Constitutional Crowdsourcing: Democratising Original and Derived Constituent Power in the Network Society, Cheltenham; Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar Publishing.
Abdrahmanov D.V. (2022) Informatsionnoe obshchestvo, tsifrovoe obshchestvo, tsifrovaya konstitutsiya [Information society, digital society, digital constitution]. In: Podshivalov T.P., Titov E.V., Gromova E.A. (eds.) Pravo tsifrovoy sredy: monografiya [Law of the digital environment: a monograph], Moscow: Prospekt, pp.220–231. (In Russian).
Atanassow E., Bartscherer T., Bateman D.A. (eds.) (2023) When the People Rule: Popular Sovereignty in Theory and Practice, New York: Cambridge University Press.
Avak'yan S.A. (2015) Konstitutsionnyy leksikon: Gosudarstvenno-pravovoy terminologicheskiy slovar' [Constitutional lexicon: dictionary of constitutional legal terms], Moscow: Yustitsinform. (In Russian).
Bachilo I.L., Lapina M.A. (eds.) (2019) Aktual'nye problemy informatsionnogo prava: uchebnik [Current problems of information law: a textbook], 2nd ed., Moscow: Yustitsiya. (In Russian).
Bates M.J. (1999) The Invisible Substrate of Information Science. Journal of the American Society for Information Science, vol.50, no.12, pp.1043–1050.
Bates M.J. (2006) Fundamental Forms of Information. Journal of the American Society for Information Science, vol.57, no.8, pp.1033–1045.
Borghi M., Brownsword R. (2023) Informational Rights and Informational Wrongs: A Tapestry for Our Times. In: Borghi M., Brownsword R. (eds.) Law, Regulation and Governance in the Information Society: Informational Rights and Informational Wrongs, Abingdon; New York: Routledge, pp.1–45.
Celeste E. (2023) Digital Constitutionalism: The Role of Internet Bills of Rights, Abingdon; New York: Routledge.
Dagger R. (1997) Civic Virtues: Rights, Citizenship, and Republican Liberalism, New York; Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Darendorf R. (2002) Sovremennyy sotsial'nyy konflikt. Ocherk politiki svobody [Contemporary social conflict. Essay on the politics of freedom], L.Yu.Pantina (transl.), Moscow: Rossiyskaya politicheskaya entsiklopediya (ROSSPEN). (In Russian).
Dworkin R. (1995) Constitutionalism and Democracy. European Journal of Philosophy, vol.3, no.1, pp.2–11.
Franklin D.P., Baun M.J. (eds.) (2015) Political Culture and Constitutionalism: A Comparative Approach, Abingdon: Routledge.
Frost R. (1964) Complete Poems of Robert Frost, New York; Chicago, IL ; San Francisco, CA: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.
Gargarella R. (2022) The Law as a Conversation Among Equals, Cambridge; New York: Cambridge University Press.
Gill L., Redeker D., Gasser U. (2015) Towards Digital Constitutionalism? Mapping Attempts to Craft an Internet Bill of Rights. Berkman Center Research Publication No.2015-15. Available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2687120 (accessed: 15.03.2024).
De Gregorio G. (2022) Digital Constitutionalism in Europe: Reframing Rights and Powers in the Algorithmic Society, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Habermas J. (2001) Vovlechenie drugogo: Ocherki politicheskoy teorii [The inclusion of the other: Studies in political theory], Yu.S.Medvedev (transl.), Saint Petersburg: Nauka. (In Russian).
Hirschman A.O. (1991) The Rhetoric of Reaction: Perversity, Futility, Jeopardy, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Howe J. (2006) The Rise of Crowdsourcing. Wired, 1 June. Available at: https://www.wired.com/2006/06/crowds/ (accessed: 15.03.2024).
Howe J. (2012) Kraudsorsing: Kollektivnyy razum kak instrument razvitiya biznesa [Crowdsourcing: why the power of the crowd is driving the future of business], Moscow: Al'pina Pablisher. (In Russian).
Howes D. (2001) e-Legislation: Law-Making in the Digital Age. McGill Law Journal, vol.47, pp.39–57.
Hundley R.O., Anderson R.H., Bikson T.K., Neu C.R. (2003) The Global Course of the Information Revolution: Recurring Themes and Regional Variations, Santa Monica, CA: RAND Corporation.
Khabrieva T.Ya., Chirkin V.E. (2007) Teoriya sovremennoy konstitutsii: monografiya [A theory of modern constitution: a monograph], Moscow: Norma. (In Russian).
Kistyakovskiy B. (1906) Gosudarstvo pravovoe i sotsialisticheskoe [The state, legal and socialist]. Voprosy filosofii i psihologii, no.85, pp.469–507. (In Russian).
Kokotov A.N. (2023) Konstitutsiya Rossii i ideologiya [The Constitution of Russia and ideology]. Aktual'nye problemy rossiyskogo prava, no.12, pp.11–23. (In Russian).
Koneva N.S. (2022) Tsifrovizatsiya gosudarstva i gosudarstvennoy vlasti [Digitalization of the state and state power]. In: Podshivalov T.P., Titov E.V., Gromova E.A. (eds.) Pravo tsifrovoy sredy: monografiya [Law of the digital environment: a monograph], Moscow: Prospekt, pp.232–244. (In Russian).
Kormilov S.I. (2001) Oksyumoron [Oxymoron]. In: Nikolyukin A.N. (ed.) Literaturnaya entsiklopediya terminov i ponyatiy [Literary encyclopedia of terms and concepts], Moscow: NPK “Intelvak”, pp.690–691. (In Russian).
Kravets I. (2023) Mnogomernyy krisis i tsifrovoe budushchee konstitutsionalisma kak mirovozzrencheskoy platformy [The multidimensional crisis and the digital future of constitutionalism as a worldview platform]. Sravnitel'noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie, vol.32, no.5, pp.11–36. (In Russian).
Kravets I. (2023) Tsifrovoe grazhdanstvo i konstitutsionnye vyzovy v informatsionnom i algoritmicheskom obshchestve [Digital citizenship and constitutional challenges in the information and algorithmic society]. Sravnitel'noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie, vol.32, no.2, pp.93–123. (In Russian).
Kravets I.A. (2016) Konstitutsiya, kraudsorsing i yuridicheskie protsedury golosovaniya: perspektivy konstitutsionnoy modernizatsii [The Constitution, crowdsourcing and legal voting procedures: prospects for constitutional modernization]. In: Tkhabisimova L.A. (ed.) Grazhdanin. Vybory. Vlast': Materialy III Mezhdunarodnoy nauchno-prakticheskoy konferentsii. Pyatigorsk, 10–11 noyabrya 2016 goda [Citizen. Elections. Power. Proceedings of the III International Scientific and Practical Conference. Pyatigorsk, 2016, 10–11 November], Pyatigorsk: Pyatigorskiy gosudarstvennyy universitet, pp.193–200. (In Russian).
Kravets I.A. (2017) Rossiyskiy konstitutsionalizm i konstitutsionnyy kraudsorsing: perspektivy konstitutsionnoy modernizatsii [Russian constitutionalism and constitutional crowdsourcing: prospects for constitutional modernization]. In: Avak'yan S.A. (ed.) Konstitutsionnoe pravo: itogi razvitiya, problemy i perspektivy: sbornik materialov mezhdunarodnoy nauchnoy konferentsii [Constitutional law: results of development, problems and prospects: proceedings of the international scientific conference], Moscow: RG-Press, pp.58–64. (In Russian).
Kravets I.A. (2018) Konstitutsionnaya modernizatsiya i konstitutsionnyy kraudsorsing: teoretiko-prikladnye aspekty i perspektivy ispol'zovaniya v konstitutsionnom pravosudii [Constitutional modernization and constitutional crowdsourcing: theoretical and applied aspects and prospects for use in constitutional justice]. In: Pravovye problemy ukrepleniya rossiyskoy gosudarstvennosti: sbornik statey po itogam Vserossiyskoy nauchno-prakticheskoy konferentsii. Posvyashchaetsya 140-letiyu Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta i 120-letiyu yuridicheskogo obrazovaniya v Sibiri, Tomsk, 25–27 yanvarya 2018 goda. Chast' 77. [Legal problems of strengthening Russian statehood: collection of articles based on the results of the All-Russian Scientific and Practical Conference. Dedicated to the 140th anniversary of Tomsk State University and the 120th anniversary of legal education in Siberia, Tomsk, January 25–27, 2018. Part 77], Tomsk: Izdatel'skiy Dom Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta, pp.75–78. (In Russian).
Kravets I.A. (2020) Informatsionnyy i tsifrovoy konstitutsionalizm i konstitutsionnye obshchestvennye initsiativy v usloviyakh rossiyskogo pravovogo prostranstva [Information and digital constitutionalism and constitutional public initiatives in conditions of the Russian legal space]. Konstitutsionnoe i munitsipal'noe pravo, no.9, pp.9–15. (In Russian).
Kravets I.A. (2020) Tsifrovoy konstitutsionalizm i budushchee informatsionnogo obshchestva (v dvadtsati godakh globalizatsii i integratsionnykh protsessov) [Digital constitutionalism and the future of the information society (in the context of globalization and integration processes)]. Pravo i gosudarstvo, no.3–4, pp.85–104. (In Russian).
Kravets I.A. (2022) Konstitutsionnye obshchestvennye initsiativy i tsifrovye konstitutsionnye prava [Constitutional public initiatives and digital constitutional rights]. In: Podshivalov T.P., Titov E.V., Gromova E.A. (eds.) Pravo tsifrovoy sredy: monografiya [Law of the digital environment: a monograph], Moscow: Prospekt, pp.212–219. (In Russian).
Kravets I.A. (2022) Kontsept “tsifrovoy konstitutsionalizm” i ego perspektivy [The concept of “digital constitutionalism” and its prospects]. In: Podshivalov T.P., Titov E.V., Gromova E.A. (eds.) Pravo tsifrovoy sredy: monografiya [Law of the digital environment: a monograph], Moscow: Prospekt, pp.200–212. (In Russian).
Kravets I.A. (2022) Tsifrovoy konstitutsionalizm: metodologicheskie i pravovye aspekty [Digital constitutionalism: methodological and legal aspects]. Gosudarstvo i pravo, no.1, pp.19–33. (In Russian).
Kravets I.A. (2022) Uchreditel'naya vlast' i sudebnyy konstitutsionalizm: teoreticheskie podkhody i konstitutsionnaya reforma 2020 goda [Constituent power and judicial constitutionalism: theoretical approaches and the 2020 constitutional reform]. Zhurnal konstitutsionnogo pravosudiya, no.1, pp.1–11. (In Russian).
Maia R.C.M. (2023) Citizens’ Assemblies and Communication Studies. In: Reuchamps M., Vrydagh J., Welp Y. (eds.) De Gruyter Handbook of Citizens’ Assemblies, Berlin; Boston, MA: De Gruyter, pp.365–378.
Medushevsky A. (2006) Pravo i novye tekhnologii: parametry regulirovaniya Interneta (Runeta) [Law and new technologies: the parameters of Internet (Runet) regulation]. Sravnitel'noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie, vol.15, no.1, pp.106–113. (In Russian).
Medushevsky A.N. (2007) Terrorism and the State: Limits of Self-Protection (The Parameters of Internet (Runet) Regulation). Cardozo Law Review, vol.29, no.1, pp.21–23.
Medushevsky A.N. (2018) Medushevsky a Law and Public Ethics: Constitution of Internet in E Government Formation (Reflections on International Debates). Forensic Research & Criminology International Journal, vol.6, no.6, pp.361–363.
Medushevsky A.N. (2019) Konstitutsiya Interneta: ideya, proekty i perspektivy [Constitution of Internet: the idea, projects and prospects]. Obshchestvennye nauki i sovremennost', no.1, pp.71–86. (In Russian).
Padovani C., Santaniello M. (2016) Call for Papers for a Special Issue of the International Communication Gazette Summer 2018 on Digital Constitutionalism: Human Rights and Power Limitation in the Internet Eco-System. The International Communication Gazette, vol.78, no.5, pp.487–489.
Pashentsev D.A., Alimova D.R. (2019) Novatsii pravotvorchestva v usloviyakh tsifrovizatsii obshchestvennykh otnosheniy [Innovations of law-making in the conditions of digitalization of public relations]. Gosudarstvo i pravo, no.6, pp.102–106. (In Russian).
Pettrachin A. (2018) Towards a Universal Declaration on Internet Rights and Freedoms? The International Communication Gazette, vol.80, no.4, pp.337–353.
Pohle J., Thiel T. (2020) Digital Sovereignty. Internet Policy Review, vol.9, no.4, pp.1–19. Available at: https://policyreview.info/pdf/policyreview-2020-4-1532.pdf (accessed: 05.03.2024).
Pollicino O., Riccio G.M., Bassini M. (eds.) (2020) Copyright and Fundamental Rights in the Digital Age: A Comparative Analysis in Search of a Common Constitutional Ground, Cheltenham; Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar Publishing.
Redeker D., Gill L., Gasser U. (2018) Towards Digital Constitutionalism? Mapping Attempts to Craft an Internet Bill of Rights. The International Communication Gazette, vol.80, no.4, pp.302–319.
Reuchamps M., Welp Y. (eds.) (2024) Deliberative Constitution-Making: Opportunities and Challenges, Abingdon: Routledge.
Robles-Carrillo M. (2023) Sovereignty vs. Digital Sovereignty. Journal of Digital Technologies and Law, vol.1, no.3, pp.673–690.
Schnapper D. (2017) The Democratic Spirit of Law, Abingdon: Routledge.
Shakespeare W. (2007) The Complete Works of William Shakespeare, Ware: Wordsworth Editions Ltd.
Shakespeare W. (2018) Otello; Makbet: tragedii [Othello; Macbeth: tragedies], B.L.Pasternak, V.Gandel'sman (transl.), Moscow: Vremya. (In Russian).
Shakhray S.M. (2018) Tsifrovaya konstitutsiya. Osnovnye prava i svobody lichnosti v total'no informatsionnom obshchestve [Digital constitution. Fundamental rights and freedoms of an individual in a total information society]. Vestnik Rossiyskoy akademii nauk, no.12, pp.1075–1082. (In Russian).
Shustrov D.G. (2022) Konstitutsiya i uchreditel'naya vlast': problema ogranicheniya [Constitution and constituent power: the problem of limitation]. Konstitutsionnoe i munitsipal'noe pravo, no.2, pp.29–39. (In Russian).
Titova E.V. (2022) Problema opredeleniya pravomernogo v tsifrovoy srede [The problem of determining what is legitimate in the digital environment]. In: Podshivalov T.P., Titov E.V., Gromova E.A. (eds.) Pravo tsifrovoy sredy: monografiya [Law of the digital environment: a monograph], Moscow: Prospekt, pp.175–182. (In Russian).
Titova E.V. (2022) Tsifrovoy konstitutsionalizm i problema pravomernosti povedeniya v Internete [Digital constitutionalism and the problem of legality of behavior on the Internet]. In: Podshivalov T.P., Titov E.V., Gromova E.A. (eds.) Pravo tsifrovoy sredy: monografiya [Law of the digital environment: a monograph], Moscow: Prospekt, pp.182–184. (In Russian).
Tsukanov Ya.A. (2018) Teoreticheskie osnovy issledovaniya kraudsorsinga i umnoy tolpy [Theoretical basis for the research of crowdsourcing and smart mobs]. Vestnik Povolzhskogo instituta upravleniya, no.3, pp.130–137. (In Russian).
Tushnet M. (1999) Taking the Constitution Away from the Courts, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Tushnet M. (2020) Taking Back the Constitution: Activist Judges and the Next Age of American Law, New Haven, CT; London: Yale University Press.
Voronov A.M. (2022) Tsifrovizatsiya gosudarstvennogo administrirovaniya [Digitalization of public administration]. In: Podshivalov T.P., Titov E.V., Gromova E.A. (eds.) Pravo tsifrovoy sredy: monografiya [Law of the digital environment: a monograph], Moscow: Prospekt, pp.244–246. (In Russian).
Vrydagh J. (2023) Citizens’ Assemblies: An Introduction. In: Reuchamps M., Vrydagh J., Welp Y. (eds.) De Gruyter Handbook of Citizens’ Assemblies, Berlin; Boston, MA: De Gruyter, pp.1–17.
Webster F. (2014) Theories of the Information Society, 4th ed., Abingdon; New York: Routledge.
Welp Y. (2022) The Will of the People. Populism and Citizen Participation in Latin America, Berlin; Boston, MA: De Gruyter.
Werhan K. (2012) Popular Constitutionalism, Ancient and Modern. University of California Davis Law Review, vol.46, pp.65–131.
Yastrembs'kaya S.V. (2022) Konstitutsionnaya kul'tura v kontekste konstitutsionalizatsii tsifrovizatsii [Constitutional culture in the context of the constitutionalization of digitalization]. In: Podshivalov T.P., Titov E.V., Gromova E.A. (eds.) Pravo tsifrovoy sredy: monografiya [Law of the digital environment: a monograph], Moscow: Prospekt, pp.247–257. (In Russian).