Available in Russian
Author: Alexander Cherkasov
DOI: 10.21128/1812-7126-2024-1-90-109
Keywords: digitalization; municipal government; public authorities; information and communication technologies; digital platforms; digital services; e-government; local democracy
In European countries major changes are taking place in the information sphere, contributing to the emergence of new forms of communication between public authorities and the population, including at the local level, which is closest to citizens. Most municipalities in European countries are actively promoting digitalization and developing their websites, taking into account expanding technological capabilities and the growing expectations of citizens. Thanks to digitalization, the latter can participate in local public debates and use municipal services while remaining within their personal space. The most important direction in modernization of local government is the creation of digital platforms through which citizens acquire the opportunity to express their opinions and participate in consultations regarding proposed public decisions. Digitalization ultimately rationalizes political participation and reduces the distance between the population and public authorities. By removing unnecessary intermediaries in relations between them, it helps overcome alienation between society and the state. Citizens now can solve many of their problems electronically without having to appear at the relevant authorities. They can monitor the activities of local politicians and officials on a regular basis via the Internet, helping to increase the transparency of these activities. While being a tool for the development of local democracy and the modernization of municipal government, digitalization at the same time entails certain “unintended negative side effects,” including the exclusion from digital communications of that part of the population which is not able to use these communications due to poor health, various age restrictions, or innate technophobia. The process of digitalization of local government is also hampered by the lack of financial resources of municipalities and by insufficient demand for online innovations both from the population and from that part of the municipal bureaucracy which inherently fears novelty and perceives the prospect of computerization of the administrative process as a direct threat of job loss.
About the author: Alexander Cherkasov – Candidate of Sciences (Ph.D.) in Law, Associate Professor, Chief Research Fellow, Human Rights Department, Institute of State and Law, Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow, Russia.
Citation: Cherkasov A. (2024) Tsifrovizatsiya mestnogo upravleniya i ee osobennosti v evropeyskikh stranakh [Digitalization of local government and its features in European countries]. Sravnitel’noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie, vol. 33, no. 1, pp. 90–109. (In Russian).
References
Ambrosino A. et al. (2023) Youth and Democracy: Digital Opportunities for the Future of Participation. In: Rouet G., Côme Th. (eds.) Participatory and Digital Democracy at the Local Level: European Discourses and Practices, Cham: Springer, pp.67–83.
Andersen K.V., Henriksen H.Z., Rasmussen E.B. (2007) Re-organising Government Using IT: The Danish Model. In: Nixon P.G., Koutrakou V.N. (eds.) E-government in Europe: Re-booting the State, London: Routledge, pp.103–118.
Beacon R. (2021) Why Local Government is the Best Laboratory of Innovation for Digital Democracy. Tony Blair Institute for Global Change, 5 May. Available at: https://www.institute.global/insights/tech-and-digitalisation/why-local-government-best-laboratory-innovation-digital-democracy (accessed: 24.01.2024).
England R.E., Pelissero J.P., Morgan D.R. (2017) Managing Urban America, Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
Falco E., Kleinhans R. (2018) Beyond Technology: Identifying Local Government Challenges for Using Digital Platforms for Citizen Engagement. International Journal of Information Management, vol.40, pp.17–20.
García D.L. (ed.) (2023) Democracy Technologies in Europe: Online Participation, Deliberation and Voting, Vienna: The Innovation in Politics Institute.
Gasco-Hernandez M., Nasi G., Cucciniello M., Hiedemann A.M. (2022) The Role of Organizational Capacity to Foster Digital Transformation in Local Governments: The Case of Three European Smart Cities. Urban Governance, vol.2, no.2, pp.236–246.
Greffet F. (2007) The Digital Republic: Renewing the French State via E-government. In: Nixon P.G., Koutrakou V.N. (eds.) E-government in Europe: Re-booting the State, London: Routledge, pp.75–89.
Karem H. (2023) Cyberdemocracy: Transforming Politics, Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
Korthagen I., Larsen C.F., Nielsen R.Ø. (2020) Non-binding Decision-Making. In: Hennen L., van Keulen I., Korthagen I., Aichholzer G., Lindner R., Nielsen R.Ø. (eds.) (2020) European E-Democracy in Practice, Cham: Springer, pp.237–271.
Kuhlmann S., Heuberger M. (2023) Digital Transformation Going Local: Implementation, Impacts and Constraints from a German Perspective. Public Money & Management, vol.43, no.2, pp.147–155.
Kuhlmann S., Proeller I., Steiner R., Marienfeldt J. (2022) Digital Transformation at the Local Tier of Government in Europe: Dynamics and Effects from a Cross-Countries and Over-Time Comparative Perspective (DIGILOG), Potsdam: University of Potsdam.
Kuhlmann S., Wayenberg E., Bergström T., Franzke J. (2021) The Essence and Transformation of Local Self-Government in Western Europe. In: Bergström T., Franzke J., Kuhlmann S., Wayenberg E. (eds.) The Future of Local Self-Government: European Trends in Autonomy, Innovations and Central-Local Relations, Cham: Palgrave Macmillan, pp.1–14.
Lips M. (2007) E-government under Construction: Challenging Traditional Conceptions of Citizenship. In: Nixon P.G., Koutrakou V.N. (eds.) E-government in Europe: Re-booting the State, London: Routledge, pp.33–47.
Lynn Th., Rosati P., Conway E., Curran D., Fox G., O’Gorman C. (2022) Digital Towns: Accelerating and Measuring the Digital Transformation of Rural Societies and Economies, Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
Mergel I. (2021) Digital Transformation of the German State. In: Kuhlmann S., Proeller I., Schimanke D., Ziekow J. (eds.) Public Administration in Germany, Cham: Palgrave Macmillan, pp.331–355.
Mesa D. (2023) Digital Divide, e-Government and Trust in Public Service: The Key Role of Education. Frontiers in Sociology, 21 February. Available at: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fsoc.2023.1140416/full (accessed: 24.01.2024).
Morio C. (2023) Evolution of the Legal Framework in Europe for the Use of Digital Participation at the “Local” Level: The French Case. In: Rouet G., Côme Th. (eds.) Participatory and Digital Democracy at the Local Level: European Discourses and Practices, Cham: Springer, pp.31–41.
Ostling A. (2022) The Pursuit of Legitimacy as a Learning Process: A Case of Local e-Participation in Sweden. In: Randma-Liiv T., Lember V. (eds.) Engaging Citizens in Policy Making: e-Participation Practices in Europe, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp.166–179.
Palos-Sánchez P.R., Baena-Luna P., Garcia-Ordaz M., Martínez-López F.J. (2023) Digital Transformation and Local Government Response to the COVID-19 Pandemic: An Assessment of Its Impact on the Sustainable Development Goals. Sage Open, vol.13, no.2, pp.1–12.
Pina V., Torres L., Royo S., Garcia-Rayado J. (2022) Decide Madrid: A Spanish Best Practice on e-Participation. In: Randma-Liiv T., Lember V. (eds.) Engaging Citizens in Policy Making: e-Participation Practices in Europe, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp.152–165.
Pleace N. (2007) E-government and the United Kingdom. In: Nixon P.G., Koutrakou V.N. (eds.) E-government in Europe: Re-booting the State, London: Routledge, pp.61–74.
Pohoryles R.J. (2017) eDemocracy, Opportunities and Challenges — The Concept of Modern Democracy and the Use of ICTs: Definitions. In: Pohoryles R., Decheva R. (eds.) eDemocracy and eParticipation: The Precious First Steps and the Way Forward, Brussels: European Liberal Forum, pp.7–11.
Randma-Liiv T., Lember V. (2022) Management and Organization of e-Participation: Synthesis from 15 European Initiatives. In: Randma-Liiv T., Lember V. (eds.) (2022) Engaging Citizens in Policy Making: e-Participation Practices in Europe, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp.260–279.
Raytcheva S. (2023) Participatory Democracy as Practice: Actors and Discourses. In: Rouet G., Côme Th. (eds.) Participatory and Digital Democracy at the Local Level: European Discourses and Practices, Cham: Springer, pp.13–29.
Rodriguez Müller A.P. (2022) Citizens’ Engagement in Policy Making: Insights from an e-Participation Platform in Leuven, Belgium. In: Randma-Liiv T., Lember V. (eds.) Engaging Citizens in Policy Making: e-Participation Practices in Europe, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp.180–195.
Rouet G., Côme Th. (2023) Introduction: Local Participatory Democracy, Discourses, and Practices in Digital Age // Participatory and Digital Democracy at the Local Level: European Discourses and Practices. In: Rouet G., Côme Th. (eds.) Participatory and Digital Democracy at the Local Level: European Discourses and Practices, Cham: Springer, pp.1–9.
Royo S., Belló B., Torres L., Downe J. (2023) The Success of E-Participation. Learning Lessons from Decide Madrid and We Asked, You Said, We Did in Scotland. Policy & Internet, 14 August. Available at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/373124937_The_success_of_e-participation_Learning_lessons_from_Decide_Madrid_and_We_asked_You_said_We_did_in_Scotland (accessed: 24.01.2024).
Silva C.N. (2022) Local Government and the COVID-19 Pandemic: An Introduction. In: Silva C.N. (ed.) Local Government and the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Global Perspective, Cham: Springer, pp.1–23.
Smith G. (2009) Democratic Innovations: Designing Institutions for Citizen Participation, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Sobaci M.Z. (2016) Social Media and Local Governments: An Overview. In: Sobaci M.Z. (ed.) Social Media and Local Governments: Theory and Practice, Cham: Springer, pp.3–21.
Śpaćek D. (2022) Connecting Participation and e-Participation: The Use of ICT in the Participatory Initiatives of Brno. In: Randma-Liiv T., Lember V. (eds.) Engaging Citizens in Policy Making: e-Participation Practices in Europe, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp.244–259.
Staykova E. (2023) The Digital Transformation of Local Democracy During the Pandemic. In: Rouet G., Côme Th. (eds.) Participatory and Digital Democracy at the Local Level: European Discourses and Practices, Cham: Springer, pp.347–360.
Troitiño D.R., Kerikmäe T., Hamuľák O. (2023) Future of the European Union. In: Troitiño D.R., Kerikmäe T., Hamuľák O. (eds.) Digital Development of the European Union: An Interdisciplinary Perspective, Cham: Springer, pp.3–6.
Troitiño D.R. (2023) Priorities and Challenges: The Digital Transition in the European Integration. In: Troitiño D.R., Kerikmäe T., Hamuľák O. (eds.) Digital Development of the European Union: An Interdisciplinary Perspective, Cham: Springer, pp.7–19.
Vitálišová K., Dvořák J. (2023) Differences and Similarities in Local Participative Governance in Slovakia and Lithuania. In: Rouet G., Côme Th. (eds.) Participatory and Digital Democracy at the Local Level: European Discourses and Practices, Cham: Springer, pp.125–146.
Vromen A. (2017) Digital Citizenship and Political Engagement: The Challenge from Online Campaigning and Advocacy Organisations, London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Weale A. (2019) Accountability and Democratic Innovations. In: Elstub St., Escobar O. (eds.) Handbook of Democratic Innovation and Governance, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp.135–147.
Wirtz B.W., Kurtz O.T. (2016) Local e-Government and User Satisfaction with City Portals — the Citizens’ Service Preference Perspective. International Review on Public and Nonprofit Marketing, vol.13, no.3, pp.265–287.
Wohlers T.E., Bernier L.L. (2016) Setting Sail into the Age of Digital Local Government: Trends and Best Practices, New York: Springer.