Available in Russian
Author: Andrey Kondrashev
Keywords: foreign agents; individual persons – foreign agents; register of non-profit organizations performing the functions of a foreign agent; responsibility for violations of the legislation on foreign agents; the law on foreign agents
The article examines the institution of a “foreign agent” that appeared in Russian legislation in 2012. The author, analyzing American legislation, the position of the Venice Commission, the Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights of the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (hereinafter – the OSCE/ODIHR), the decisions of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation, as well as the existing Russian judicial practice, comes to the conclusion that ’misappropriation’ status of a foreign agent by the Ministry of Justice of Russia for non-profit organizations (hereinafter – NPOs) occurs in the absence of clear legal definition of the term “political activity”, does not correlate with the identification of the real connection and activities of NPOs on the order or instruction of a foreign donor, and is actually applied in those cases when it comes to appeals to government agencies, criticism of government agencies or assessment of their decisions. All this indicates that the purpose of the restrictions imposed by the state was by no means a desire to ensure transparency and openness through access to information about foreign financing of non-profit organizations, but rather the purpose was to politically stigmatize and impose additional organizational and financial burdens on NPOs, which dare to criticize the authorities. The author advocates the complete abolition of this institution of a foreign agent, since the pre-existing Russian legislation already made it possible to exercise control over the financing and activities of NPOs. The expansion of the number of types of foreign agents, introduced since December 2019 (first in terms of recognition by media as foreign agents), led by December 2020 to the appearance in Russian legislation of individuals of foreign agents and foreign agents-unregistered public associations and even greater and disproportionate restrictions on the constitutional the right to association. Moreover, the status of a “foreign agent” (in relation to a candidate for an elective office and a candidate affiliated with an acting foreign agent) is supposed to be introduced into the electoral legislation with the obvious goal of political stigmatization of persons trying to exercise their passive electoral right.
About the author: Andrey Kondrashev – Doctor of Sciences in Law, Professor, Law Institute Siberian Federal University, Krasnoyarsk, Russia.
Citation: Kondrashev A. (2021) Inostrannye agenty v Rossii: kak zaimstvovannyy amerikanskiy pravovoy institut priobryol inoy smysl v rossiyskom zakonodatel’stve i pravoprimenitel’noy praktike [Foreign agents in Russia: How a borrowed American legal institute acquired a different sense in Russian legislation and law enforcement practices]. Sravnitel'noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie, vol. 30, no. 4, pp. 97–121. (In Russian).
Alen'kin I.V. (2016) Inostrannye agenty: nuzhny li kontrreformy? [Foreign agents: are counter-reforms needed?]. Konstitutsionnoe i munitsipal'noe pravo, no.6, pp.21–28. (In Russian).
Averkina Yu.B. (2014) Nekotorye voprosy pravovogo polozheniya nekommercheskikh organizatsiy, vypolnyayushchikh funktsii inostrannogo agenta [Some questions of the legal status of non-profit organizations performing functions of the foreign agents]. Vestnik Saratovskoy gosudarstvennoy yuridicheskoy akademii, no.3, pp.137–141. (In Russian).
Chirkin V.E. (2013) Slovo o konstitutsionnoy terminologii [A word about constitutional terminology]. Zhurnal rossiyskogo prava, no.12, pp.13–19. (In Russian).
Douek E. (2018) What’s in Australia’s New Laws on Foreign Interference in Domestic Politics. Lawfare. 11 July. Available at: https://www.lawfareblog.com/whats-australias-new-laws-foreign-interference-domestic-politics (accessed: 02.08.2021).
Gavrilova A.B. (2019) Fenomen “inostrannogo agenta” na postsovetskom prostranstve [Phenomenon of “foreign agent” on post-Soviet area]. In: Konstitutsiya i obshchestvennyy progress. Vtorye Prokop'evskie chteniya: materialy mezhdunarodnoy nauchno-prakticheskoy konferentsii [The Constitution and social progress. Second Prokop'ev readings: proceedings of the international scientific and practical conference], Kaliningrad: Baltiyskiy federal'nyy universitet imeni Immanuila Kanta, pp.90–102. (In Russian).
Korneychuk B.V. (2013) Institutsional'nyy analiz zakona “ob inostrannykh agentakh” v nekommercheskom sektore [The institutional analysis of the law on “foreign agents” in non-government sector]. Ekonomika i predprinimatel'stvo, no.10, pp.524–527. (In Russian).
Kupina N.A. (2012) Ideologema “inostrannyy agent”: tri dnya v iyule 2012 goda [Ideologem “foreign agent”: 3 days in July 2012]. Politicheskaya lingvistika, no.3, pp.43–48. (In Russian).
Kurbanov R.A., Shvedkova O.V., Belyalova A.M. (2016) Ogranicheniya na dostup k finansirovaniyu, v tom chisle iz inostrannykh istochnikov: mezhdunarodnye i regional'nye standarty, opyt Rossii i zarubezhnykh stran [Limited access to financing, including funding from foreign sources: international and regional standards, Russian and foreign experience]. Ekonomika. Pravo. Obshchestvo, no.3, pp.25–38. (In Russian).
Mikhaylov V.K. (2015) Kriticheskiy vzglyad na pozitsiyu Konstitutsionnogo Suda po usloviyam priznaniya nekommercheskoy organizatsii inostrannym agentom [A critical view of the position of the Constitutional Court on the conditions for recognition of a non-profit organization as a foreign agent]. Pravo i sovremennye gosudarstva, no.1, pp.17–28. (In Russian).
Polyakov A.I., Cherdakov O.I. (2015) Nepravitel'stvennye obshhestvennye organizatsii v pravovoy srede sovremennoy Rossii [Non-governmental public organizations in the legal environment of modern Russia]. Yuridicheskaya nauka, no.2, pp.13–16. (In Russian).
Vasilenko A.I. (2014) Prinyatie zakona “Ob inostrannykh agentakh” kak pervyy etap na puti k pravovomu regulirovaniyu lobbistskoy deyatel'nosti v Rossii [Adopting of the Foreign Agents Act as a first stage towards legal regulation of lobbying in Russia]. Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Yuridicheskie nauki, no.3, pp.44–58. (In Russian).