Forms of government and party systems in Latvia, Lithuania and Estonia: 30 years of independence

This article focuses on the peculiarities of government forms in Baltic states that were once part of the USSR: Latvia, Lithuania and Estonia. The constitutional and legal bases of relations between presidents and their parliaments and governments are considered in detail, and the author makes a comparative analysis of institutions operating in these states. This article also examines the grounds for the resignation of governments, their heads, and individual ministers, as well as discussing the features of the party and electoral systems of these Baltic States. These systems’ functions face several problems, and forms of government like semi-presidential and parliamentary republics are shown to lack effectiveness across the Baltic States. It is important to note the instability of these governments, which changed every two and a half years on average, although this did not affect the countries’ economies. The presidents of these republics performed political mediation effectively and ensured a constant dialogue with political forces. Since national governments were formed on a non-coalition basis in all three States, an extensive practice of inter-party agreements and alliances began. This created a new type of political culture, where prejudice towards the Russian communities of the states in Latvia and Estonia was prevalent, and this issue is addressed in the article.

About the author: Ilya Shablinsky* – Doctor of Science in Law, Professor of Constitutional and Administrative Law, Higher School of Economics, Moscow, Russia.

Citation: Shablinsky I.* (2021) Formy pravleniya i partiynye sistemy v Latvii, Litve i Estonii: 30 let nezavisimosti [Forms of government and party systems in Latvia, Lithuania and Estonia: 30 years of independence]. Sravnitel'noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie, vol. 30, no. 5, pp. 138–156. (In Russian).

References

(2018) Monitoring konstitutsionnykh novostey: sentyabr'—noyabr' 2018 [Constitutional watch: September—November 2018]. Sravnitel'noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie, vol.27, no.6, pp.4–12. (In Russian).

Buzaev V.V. (2017) Grazhdane i “negrazhdane”. Politiko-pravovoe razdelenie zhiteley Latvii v postsovetskiy period [Citizens and “non-citizens”. The political and legal division of Latvian residents in the post-Soviet period], Moscow: Assotsiatsiya knigoizdateley “Russkaya kniga”. (In Russian).

Megem M.E., Rekeda S.V. (2014) Sistema finansirovaniya politicheskikh partiy Latvii [The system of financing of political parties in Latvia]. Vestnik Baltiyskogo federal'nogo universiteta imeni I.Kanta, no.6, pp.103–111. (In Russian).

Olenchenko V. (2014) Krizis evroatlantizma v Pribaltike. Vybornyy protsess vyyavil peremeny v nastroeniyakh izbitateley [Crisis of Euro-Atlanticism in the Baltics. Election process revealed changes in voter sentiment]. Nezavisimaya gazeta, no.93 (6141). 13 May. (In Russian).

Smirnov V.A. (2015) K voprosu o krizisnykh tendentsiyakh v sfere legitimnosti politicheskikh rezhimov stran Pribaltiki [On crisis trends in the legitimacy of the political regimes of the Baltic States]. Baltiyskiy region, no.4, pp.51–72. (In Russian).

Sobina A. (2004) U Litvy budet novyy Prezident [Lithuania will have a new President]. Rossiyskaya gazeta, no.0 (3443). 1 April. (In Russian).

Vorotnikov V. (2018) Partiya “Soglasie” na parlamentskikh vyborakh v Latvii 2018 goda: pobeda bez pobeditelya [“Harmony” party in the 2018 parliamentary elections in Latvia: victory with no winner]. Nauchno-analiticheskiy vestnik Instituta Evropy Rossiyskoy akademii nauk, no.5, pp.85–90. (In Russian).

Vorotnikov V.V. (2016) 25 let nezavisimosti gosudarstv Baltii: iz Sovetskogo v Evropeyskiy Soyuz [25 years of independence in the Baltic States: from the Soviet to the European Union]. Kontury global'nykh transformatsiy: politika, ekonomika, pravo, no.5, pp.7–23. (In Russian).

Zake L. (2007) Authoritarianism and political ideas of Latvian nationalist intellectuals. Journal of Baltic Studies, vol.38, no.3, pp.291–315.

* Recognised as a foreign agent in Russia