Available in Russian
Authors: Kirill Sukhanov, Vladimir Kryazhkov
DOI: 10.21128/1812-7126-2023-6-90-115
Keywords: national minorities; indigenous peoples; indigenous small-numbered peoples; traditional way of life; acquisition and loss of the status of an ethnic community; ethnic communities of Northern Europe; ethnic self-identification
The Constitution of the Russian Federation has various concepts of ethnic communities, including national minorities and indigenous small-numbered peoples. Despite their constitutional distinction, these communities are sometimes considered synonymously in legislation, law enforcement practice, and doctrine. The specification of these concepts is further complicated by the fact that Russia ceased its participation in European international obligations protecting the rights of national minorities and withdrew from the Barents Euro-Arctic Council, including its dealings with problems of indigenous peoples. The question of Russia’s participation in the Arctic Council, whose activities also cover the rights of indigenous peoples, remains open. This article attempts to clarify the current legal status of national minorities and small indigenous small-numbered peoples in the Russian Federation. It discusses the historical prerequisites for the formation of these ethnic communities in the Russian Empire and during the Soviet period, the peculiarities of their identification from the standpoint of current Russian and international law, the correlation of these communities according to the catalog of rights guaranteed to them, and the methods of their acquiring and losing their corresponding status. In addition, the experience of defining national minorities and indigenous peoples in the Nordic countries (Sweden, Finland, Norway and Denmark) is examined in a comparative legal analysis. The authors conclude that national minorities and indigenous small-numbered peoples in the Russian Federation do have some similar features but still differ from each other. Indigenous are distinguished by their special historical connection with their ancestral territories of residence, which predetermines special legal regulation of the status of these peoples. Taking into account this circumstance, the article supports the usefulness of further development of Russian legislation on national minorities and indigenous small-numbered peoples, including taking into account the practices of foreign countries while noting their differences.
About the authors: Kirill Sukhanov – Candidate of Sciences (Ph.D.) in Law, Moscow, Russia; Vladimir Kryazhkov – Doctor of Sciences in Law, Professor, Research Professor of the Department of Public Law, Faculty of Law, Higher School of Economics, Honored Lawyer of the Russian Federation, Moscow, Russia.
Citation: Kryazhkov V., Sukhanov K. (2023) Natsional’nye men’shinstva i korennye malochislennye narody v Rossii: pravovye problemy identifikatsii [National minorities and small indigenous peoples in Russia: legal problems of their identification]. Sravnitel’noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie, vol. 32, no. 6, pp. 90–115. (In Russian).
References
Åkermark S.S. (2015) Divergence and Convergence in Minority Law and Policies in the Nordic Countries. Available at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/285171596_Divergence_and_convergence_in_minority_law_and_policies_in_the_Nordic_Countries (accessed: 09.11.2023).
Alektorov A.E. (1906) Inorodtsy v Rossii. Sovremennye voprosy. Finlyandtsy. Polyaki. Latyshi. Evrei. Nemtsy. Armyane. Tatary [Inorodtsy in Russia. Contemporary issues. Finnish people. Poles. Latvians. Jews. Germans. Armenians. Tatars], Saint Petersburg: Obshchestvo revniteley russkogo istoricheskogo prosveshcheniya v pamyat’ imperatora Aleksandra III. (In Russian).
Avakyan S.A. (2014) Konstitutsionnoe parvo Rossii: Uchebnyy kurs. Tom 1 [Constitutional law of Russia: Training course. Vol.1], in 2 vols., 5th ed., Moscow: Norma: INFRA-M. (In Russian).
Barbieri S. (2013) Natsional’no-kul’turnye avtonomii kak instrument upravleniya mezhetnicheskimi otnosheniyami: istoricheskiy obzor [National-cultural autonomies as a tool for diversity management: a historical review]. Sotsial’nye yavleniya, no. 2, pp. 6–21. (In Russian).
Boytsov V.Ya. (1972) Sistema sub’ektov sovetskogo gosudarstvennogo prava [The system of subjects of Soviet state law], Ufa: Bashkirskoe knizhnoe izdatel’stvo. (In Russian).
Dönninghaus V. (2011) V teni “Bol’shogo Brata”: zapadnye national’nye men’shinstva v SSSR 1917–1938 gg. [In the shadow of “Big Brother”: Western national minorities in the USSR (1917–1938)], V. Dönninghaus (transl.), A.I. Savin (ed.), Moscow: Rossiyskaya politicheskaya entsiklopediya. (In Russian).
Gladun E.F., Zadorin M.Yu., Gorbunova A.I. (2023) Regional’nye praktiki zashchity prav korennykh malochislennykh narodov Rossiyskoy Arktiki [Regional practices for the protection of indigenous peoples’ rights of the Russian Arctic]. Voprosy gosudarstvennogo i munitsipal’nogo upravleniya, no. 3, pp. 122–154. (In Russian).
Gradovskiy A.D. (1875) Nachala russkogo gosudarstvennogo prava [The beginnings of Russian state law], vol. 1, Saint Petersburg: Tipografiya M.Stasyulevicha. (In Russian).
Hirsch F. (2021) Imperiya natsiy. Etnograficheskoe znanie i formirovanie Sovetskogo Soyuza [Empire of nations. Ethnographic knowledge and the making of the Soviet Union], R. Ibatullin (transl.), Moscow: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. (In Russian).
Irkhin I.V. (2019) Konstitutsionno-pravovoy status lits, postoyanno prozhivayushchikh v mestakh traditsionnogo prozhivaniya i traditsionnoy khozyaystvennoy deyatel’nosti korennykh malochislennykh narodov Rossii [Constitutional and legal status of persons not belonging to the indigenous peoples of Russia, but permanently residing in the places of their traditional residence and traditional economic activity]. Zhurnal rossiyskogo prava, no. 5, pp. 31–39. (In Russian).
Karapetyan L.M. (1996) Federativnoe gosudarstvo i pravovoy status narodov [The federal state and the legal status of peoples], Moscow: Manuskript. (In Russian).
Kaykova O.K. (2007) Natsional’nye rayony i sel’sovety v RSFSR: istoricheskiy opyt Sovetskogo gosudarstva v reshenii problem natsional’nykh men’shinstv v 1920–1941 gg.: Avtoref. dis. … kand. ist. nauk [National districts and village councils in the RSFSR: the historical experience of the Soviet state in solving the problem of national minorities in 1920–1941: Abstract of a dissertation … candidate of historical sciences], Moscow. (In Russian).
Kokotov A.N. (1994) Russkaya natsiya i rossiyskaya gosudarstvennost’ [Russian nation and Russian statehood], Yekaterinburg: Izdatel’stvo Ural’skoy gosudarstvennoy yuridicheskoy akademii. (In Russian).
Korkunov N.M. (1909) Russkoe gosudarstvennoe pravo. Tom 1 [Russian state law. Vol.1], in 2 vols., 6th ed., Saint Petersburg: Tipografiya М.M.Stasyulevicha. (In Russian).
Kryazhkov V.A. (2010) Korennye malochislennye narody Severa v rossiyskom prave [Indigenous small-numbered peoples of the North in Russian law], Moscow: Norma. (In Russian).
Kryazhkov V.A. (2023) Mesta traditsionnogo prozhivaniya i traditsionnoy khozyaystvennoy deyatel’nosti korennykh malochislennykh narodov Severa, Sibiri i Dal’nego Vostoka Rossii: pravovoy aspect [Places of traditional residence and traditional economic activity of indigenous small-numbered peoples of the North, Siberia and the Far East of Russia: legal aspect]. Gosudarstvo i pravo, no. 8, pp. 84–95. (In Russian).
Lukin Yu.F. (2012) O russkom pomore zamolvite slovo [About Russian Pomor say a word]. Arktika i Sever, no. 7, pp. 3–9. (In Russian).
Malakhov V.S., Osipov A.G. (2008) Kategoriya “etnicheskoe men’shinstvo” v rossiyskom publichnom i zakonodatel’nom diskursakh [“Ethnic minority” as a category of Russian public and legislative discourses]. Mir Rossii, no. 3, pp. 67–91. (In Russian).
Mochalov A.N. (2017) Pravovoe polozhenie natsional’nykh men’shinstv: obzor nekotorykh podkhodov v mezhdunarodnom prave [The legal status of national minorities: the overview of some approaches in international law]. Elektronnoe prilozhenie k “Rossiyskomu yuridicheskomu zhurnalu”, no. 4, pp. 53–68. (In Russian).
Panchenko A.B., Stafeev O.N. (2018) Inorodcheskiy vopros v diskursakh Rossiyskoy imperii: mezhdu potrebnostyami gosudarstva i predstavitelyami obshchestva [Inorodtsy’s question in the discourse of the Russian Empire: between government needs and society images]. Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta, no. 436, pp. 164–174. (In Russian).
Pogodin S.N., Lyubina D.E. (2021) Osobennosti vnutrenney avtonomii Alandskikh ostrovov v sostave Finlyandii [Features of internal autonomy of the Aland Islands within Finland]. Upravlencheskoe konsul’tirovanie, no. 1, pp. 88–96. (In Russian).
Polyan P.M. (2001) Ne po svoey vole… Istoriya i geografiya prinuditel’nykh migratsiy v SSSR [Not of one’s own free will… History and geography of forced migrations in the USSR], Moscow: “OGI”; “Memorial”. (In Russian).
Popkov Yu.V. (2023) “Pochva” v etnichnosti: traditsii otechestvennogo narodovedeniya v ispytanii “perestroykoy” i postmodernizmom (postanovka problemy) [“Soil” in ethnicity: traditions of Russian ethnology tested by “perestroika” and postmodernism (problem statement)]. Novye issledovaniya Tuvy, no. 1, pp. 137–153. (In Russian).
Sandberg J. (2002) Human Rights in Sweden. Revista IIDH, vol. 36, pp. 107–127.
Semushkin D. (2013) “Pomorskiy vopros” i Russkaya Arktika: sbornik statey [The “Pomor question” and the Russian Arctic: a collection of articles], M.A.Kolerov (ed.), Moscow: Izdatel’skiy dom “REGNUM”. (In Russian).
Simon G. (1986) Nationalismus und Nationalitätenpolitik in der Sowjetunion: Von der Totalitären Diktatur zur Nachstalinschen Gesellschaft, Baden-Baden: Nomos.
Sokolovskiy S.V. (2016) Politika priznaniya korennykh narodov v mezhdunarodnom prave i v zakonodatel’stve Rossiyskoy Federatsii [The policy of recognition of indigenous peoples in international law and in the legislation of the Russian Federation], Moscow: Institut etnologii i antropologii Rossiyskoy akademii nauk. (In Russian).
Stalin I.V. (1936) O proekte Konstitutsii Soyuza SSR: Doklad na Chrezvychaynom VIII Vsesoyuznom s’ezde Sovetov 25 noyabrya 1936 goda [On the draft Constitution of the USSR: Report at the Extraordinary VIII All-Union Congress of Soviets on November 25, 1936], Moscow: Partizdat. (In Russian).
Sukhanov K.A. (2022) Natsional’nye men’shinstva Rossiyskoy Federatsii – kto oni? [National minorities of the Russian Federation – who are they?]. Trudy Instituta gosudarstva i prava RAN, no. 4, pp. 205–227. (In Russian).
Voevodin L.D. (1972) Konstitutsionnye prava i obyazannosti sovetskikh grazhdan [Constitutional rights and duties of Soviet citizens], Moscow: Izdatel’stvo Moskovskogo universiteta. (In Russian).
Yudin V.I. (2011) Gosudarstvennaya politika Norvegii v otnoshenii naroda Saami: pravovye osnovaniya i sotsiokul’turnye protivorechiya [State policy of Norway towards the Sami people: legal grounds and sociocultural contradictions]. Vlast’, no. 12, pp. 183–186. (In Russian).
Zadorin M.Yu. (2011) Rossiyskie pomory i kanadskie metisy: etnografiya i pravo [Russian Pomors and Canadian mestizos: ethnography and law]. Kazanskaya nauka, no. 9, pp. 177–181. (In Russian).
Zadorin M.Yu. (2012) 10 mifov o “Pomorskom vozrozhdenii” i ikh oproverzhenie: pravovaya perspektiva [10 myths about the “Pomeranian Revival” and their refutation: a legal perspective].
Tsentr L’va Gumileva, 4 April. Available at: https://www.gumilev-center.ru/10-mifov-o-pomorskom-vozrozhdenii-i-ikh-oproverzhenie-pravovaya-perspektiva/?ysclid=ln33n74ep6607216190 (accessed: 09.11.2023). (In Russian).
Zadorin M.Yu. (2015) Konstitutsionnoe pravo korennykh malochislennykh narodov na razvitie: Dis. … kand. yurid. nauk [Constitutional right of indigenous small-numbered peoples to development: Cand. in law sci. diss.], Moscow. (In Russian).
Zadorin M.Yu., Kotlova E.S. (2019) The “Hybrid Model” of Norway’s Ethnic Policy in Its Northern Counties: A Key to Stable Interethnic Relations. Baltic Region, vol. 11, no. 2, pp. 4–16.
Zametina T.V. (2009) Konstitutsionnyy status korennykh malochislennykh narodov: monografiya [Constitutional status of indigenous small-numbered peoples: a monograph], Engels: Redaktsionno-izdatel’skiy tsentr Povolzhskogo kooperativnogo instituta. (In Russian).
Ziganshin I. (2014) Natsional’nye men’shinstva Shvetsii: konstitutsionno-pravovye osnovy (na primere korennogo naroda saami) [National minorities in Sweden: constitutional and legal foundations (the case of the Sami indigenous people)]. Sravnitel’noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie, vol. 23, no. 4, pp. 10–16. (In Russian).