Available in Russian
DOI: 10.21128/1812-7126-2025-1-4-20
Author: Alexander Cherkasov
Keywords: digital democracy; digital participation; innovations; social networks; public authorities; e-government; the problem of digital representation; digital absenteeism
The development of digital democracy in European countries involves the active introduction of modern technologies and the promotion of digitalization in order to strengthen the political system and protect human rights and freedoms. Digital democracy helps to bridge the existing gap between civil society and the state, to eliminate unnecessary links in the relationship between them and to rationalize political participation. In the course of digitalization, new mechanisms are opening up for identifying the opinions of the population and involving them in the solving of the most significant issues of social and political life. Social networks play a significant role by providing up-to-date information in real time and helping to eliminate traditional barriers to civic participation, such as distance or social pressure. Digital democracy promotes the introduction of the institute of “electronic government”, which makes the services provided by public authorities accessible to the population almost around the clock. There is increasing differentiation in the provision of services, which are, as it were, “tailored” for each specific individual, perceived, first of all, as a client of the public administration. Automation of services, provided to citizens, helps to reduce possible human errors when entering data and guarantees a certain impartiality on the part of public authorities. Thanks to digital democracy, the crisis of legitimacy characteristic of representative democracy, caused by a loss of trust in existing political institutions, is largely overcome. In the context of digitalization, citizens gain much greater access to objective information and become less dependent on traditional sources of information, which largely determined their political views. Digital democracy also contributes to the development of participatory democracy, helping to overcome civic apathy and increase citizen participation in public politics. The use of digital technologies in everyday life, however, not only provides additional opportunities for growth and development, but also creates new risks. The development of digital democracy is hampered by the possibility of manipulating the consciousness of the population and the dissemination of information that does not correspond to reality. Citizens are often bombarded with a large stream of unfiltered news, so it can be difficult for them to distinguish what is true from fake information, which can be quite skillfully constructed using modern technologies. The so-called digital divide, defined as the inability of part of the population to properly use modern means of communication, remains a significant problem.
About the author: Alexander Cherkasov – Candidate of Sciences (Ph.D.) in Law, Associate Professor, Senior Research Fellow, Human Rights Department, Institute of State and Law, Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow, Russia.
Citation:
Cherkasov A. (2025) Tsifrovaya demokratiya i eyo osobennosti: opyt evropeyskikh stran [E-democracy and its features: the experience of European countries]. Sravnitel'noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie, vol.34, no.1, pp.4–20. (In Russian).
References
Bastick Z. (2017) Digital Limits of Government: The Failure of E-Democracy. In: Paulin A.A., Anthopoulos L.G., Reddick C.G. (eds.) Beyond Bureaucracy: Towards Sustainable Governance Informatisation, Cham: Springer, pp.3–14.
Berg S., Hofmann J. (2021) Digital Democracy. Internet Policy Review, vol.10, no.4. Available at: https://policyreview.info/pdf/policyreview-2021-4-1612.pdf (accessed: 23.01.2025).
Buchstein H. (1997) Bytes that Bite: The Internet and Deliberative Democracy. Constellations, vol.4, no.2, pp.248–263.
Castelfranchi C., Falcone R. (2019) The Problematic Relationship Between Trust and Democracy; Its Crisis and Web Dangers and Promises. In: Contucci P., Omicini A., Pianini D., Sîrbu A. (eds.) The Future of Digital Democracy: An Interdisciplinary Approach, Cham: Springer, pp.62–82.
Contucci P., Omicini A., Pianini D., Sirbu A. (2019) Preface. In: Contucci P., Omicini A., Pianini D., Sirbu A. (eds.) The Future of Digital Democracy: An Interdisciplinary Approach, Cham: Springer, pp. V–VIII.
Cropf R. (2018) The Challenges in Implementing E-Democracy in the United States. In: Saeed S., Ramayah T., Mahmood Z. (eds.) User Centric E-Government: Challenges and Opportunities, Cham: Springer, pp.3–22.
Đurman P., Musa A., Koprić I. (2022) Participatory Law-Making in the Digital Age: The Case of the E-Public Consultation Platform in Croatia. In: Randma-Liiv T., Lember V. (eds.) Engaging Citizens in Policy Making: E-Participation Practices in Europe, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp.91–103.
Falanga R., Lüchmann L.H.H. (2019) Participatory Budgets in Brazil and Portugal: Comparing Patterns of Dissemination. Policy Studies, vol.41, no.6, pp.603–622.
Hague B.N., Loader B.D. (2005) Digital Democracy: An Introduction. In: Hague B.N., Loader B.D. (eds.) Digital Democracy: Discourse and Decision Making in the Information Age, London; New York: Routledge, pp.3–22.
Jakus D. (2017) Croatia — Modernizing, Simplifying and Speeding Up Communication Between Citizens and Administration. In: Pohoryles R., Decheva R. (eds.) E-Democracy and E-Participation: The Precious First Steps and the Way Forward, Brussels: European Liberal Forum, pp.63–65.
Karem H. (2023) Cyberdemocracy: Transforming Politics, Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
Kirjavainen H., Jalonen H. (2023) Digital Co-Creation — Mission (Im)possible? In: Väyrynen H., Helander N., Jalonen H. (eds.) Public Innovation and Digital Transformation, London: Routledge, pp.13–31.
Korovkin V., Park A., Kaganer E.A. (2022) Towards Conceptualization and Quantification of the Digital Divide. Information Communication and Society, vol.26, no.11, pp.2268–2303.
Larus J.R. (2024) Evolution of Computing. In: Werthner H., Ghessi C., Kramer J., Nida-Rümelin J., Nuseibeh B., Prem E., Stranger A. (eds.) Introduction to Digital Humanism: A Textbook, Cham: Springer, pp.31–45.
Lindner R., Aichholzer G. (2020) E-Democracy: Conceptual Foundation and Recent Trends. In: Hennen L., van Keulen I., Korthagen I., Aichholzer G., Lindner R., Nielsen R.Ø. (eds.) European E-Democracy in Practice, Cham: Springer, pp.11–46.
Lips M. (2020) Digital Government: Managing Public Sector Reform in the Digital Era, Abingdon; New York: Routledge.
Lüchmann L.H.H. (2017) Participatory Budgeting and Democratic Innovation: Some Analytical Variables. In: Paulin A.A., Anthopoulos L.G., Reddick C.G. (eds.) Beyond Bureaucracy: Towards Sustainable Governance Informatisation, Cham: Springer, pp.63–78.
Lynn T., Rosati P., Conway E., Curran D., Fox G., O’Gorman C. (2022) Digital Towns: Accelerating and Measuring the Digital Transformation of Rural Societies and Economies, Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
Makowski G. (2017) From Weber to the Web… Can ICT Reduce Bureaucratic Corruption? In: Paulin A.A., Anthopoulos L.G., Reddick C.G. (eds.) Beyond Bureaucracy: Towards Sustainable Governance Informatisation, Cham: Springer, pp.291–312.
Margolis M., Moreno-Riaño G. (2009) The Prospect of Internet Democracy, Farnham: Ashgate Publishing.
Metakides G. (2024) Democracy in the Digital Era. In: Werthner H., Ghessi C., Kramer J., Nida-Rümelin J., Nuseibeh B., Prem E., Stranger A. (eds.) Introduction to Digital Humanism: A Textbook, Cham: Springer, pp.495–510.
Milakovich M.E. (2012) Digital Governance: New Technologies for Improving Public Service and Participation, New York: Routledge.
De Morais C.B. (2022) “Digital Democracy”: A Threat to the Democratic System or Oxygenation of Representative Democracy and Free Speech? In: de Morais C.B., Mendes G.F., Vesting T. (eds.) The Rule of Law in Cyberspace, Cham: Springer, pp.9–64.
Randma-Liiv T., Lember V. (2022) Management and Organization of E-Participation: Synthesis from 15 European Initiatives. In: Randma-Liiv T., Lember V. (eds.) Engaging Citizens in Policy Making: E-Participation Practices in Europe, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp.260–279.
Śpaćek D. (2022) Connecting Participation and E-Participation: The Use of ICT in the Participatory Initiatives of Brno. In: Randma-Liiv T., Lember V. (eds.) Engaging Citizens in Policy Making: E-Participation Practices in Europe, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp.244–259.
Staykova E. (2023) The Digital Transformation of Local Democracy During the Pandemic. In: Rouet G., Côme T. (eds.) Participatory and Digital Democracy at the Local Level: European Discourses and Practices, Cham: Springer, pp.347–360.
Svensson S., Molnar A., Batory A. (2022) (E-)Participation and Propaganda: The Mix of Old and New Technology in Hungarian National Consultations. In: Randma-Liiv T., Lember V. (eds.) Engaging Citizens in Policy Making: E-Participation Practices in Europe, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp.56–70.
Swart J., Peters C., Broersma M. (2018) New Rituals for Public Connection: Audiences’ Everyday Experiences of Digital Journalism, Civic Engagement and Social Life. In: Schwanholz J., Graham T., Stoll P-T. (eds.) Managing Democracy in the Digital Age: Internet Regulation, Social Media Use, and Online Civic Engagement, Cham: Springer, pp.181–200.
Unver H.A. (2017) Digital Challenges to Democracy: Politics of Automation, Attention, and Engagement. Journal of International Affairs, vol.71, no.1, pp.127–146.
Van Dijk J. (2020) The Digital Divide, Cambridge: Polity.
Weinhardt C., Fegert J., Hinz O., van der Aalst W.M.P. (2024) Digital Democracy: A Wake-Up Call. How IS Research Can Contribute to Strengthening the Resilience of Modern Democracies. Business & Information Systems Engineering, vol.66, no.2, pp.127–134.
Werthner H. (2024) Digital Transformation, Digital Humanism: What Needs to Be Done. In: Werthner H., Ghessi C., Kramer J., Nida-Rümelin J., Nuseibeh B., Prem E., Stranger A. (eds.) Introduction to Digital Humanism: A Textbook, Cham: Springer, pp.115–134.
Werthner H., Ghessi C., Kramer J., Nida-Rümelin J., Nuseibeh B., Prem E., Stranger A. (2024) Preface. In: Werthner H., Ghessi C., Kramer J., Nida-Rümelin J., Nuseibeh B., Prem E., Stranger A. (eds.) Introduction to Digital Humanism: A Textbook, Cham: Springer, pp. V–X.
Wirtz B.W. (2022) Digital Government: Strategy, Government Models and Technology, Cham: Springer.
Yavuz N. (2023) Digital Divide and Citizen Participation in Public Policy. In: Göçoğlu V., Karkin N. (eds.) Citizen-Centered Public Policy Making in Turkey, Cham: Springer, pp.115–130.