Available in Russian
Author: Vadim Korolkov
DOI: 10.21128/1812-7126-2025-1-95-119
Keywords: federalism; local government reform; municipalities; comparative studies
The federal structure of a state as a special kind of multilevel system of governance gives an additional dimension to the theoretical discussion about the “social” or “state” nature of local self-government. Both of these approaches can have different institutional manifestations and that is why they cannot be considered decisive characteristics that allow for an unambiguous qualification of the institutional design of public authority unless a number of essential factors are taken into account. The general logic and the main trends in the development of federal systems as a special kind of multilevel governance is one such factor that must be taken into account not only in the process of cognitive activity, but also in the long-term strategic planning of social development. A closer look at several heterogeneous federal systems reveals one of the stable trends that have emerged in recent decades: the progressive and multidimensional inclusion of local self-government institutions in the multilevel system of public power institutions. The Russian experience in this respect follows the general trend, but not always consistently for political reasons. With the new law “On the general principles of organisation of local self-government in the unified system of public authority” was recently passed, this paper analyses three models of the organisational correlation between federalism and local self-government: the full attribution of local government to the exclusive competence of the entities of the federation; the establishment of the general foundations of the local level of government in federal constitutional legislation, with subsequent detailing within the framework of the legislation of the constituent entities; and the full inclusion of local government institutions as full members of the federative system. The nine federal states chosen for the analysis represent a broad sample of cases, allowing us to draw conclusions about how each of the three models works under different social conditions, which is made possible by the methodology of critical realism. The comparative study is not focused on reaching general conclusions, but on the application of the experience of foreign federal systems to the main provisions of the new law under discussion and subjecting it to scholarly criticism.
About the author: Vadim Korolkov – Candidate of Sciences (Ph.D.) in Law, Assistant, Constitutional and Municipal Law Department, Faculty of Law, Lomonosov Moscow State University, Head of the Federalists Discussion Club, Moscow, Russia.
Citation:
Korolkov V. (2025) Munitsipal'naya reforma v Rossii v kontekste mirovykh modeley organizatsii mestnogo samoupravleniya v federativnykh sistemakh [Municipal reform in Russia in the context of world models of local government organisation in federal systems]. Sravnitel'noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie, vol.34, no.1, pp.95–119. (In Russian).
References
Aulich C., Pietsch R. (2002) Left on the Shelf: Local Government and the Australian Constitution. Australian Journal of Public Administration, vol.61, no.4, pp.14–23.
Bazhenova O.I. (2019) K probleme realizatsii konstitutsionnogo poselenchesko-territorial'nogo printsipa organizatsii mestnogo samoupravleniya. V zashchitu poselencheskogo nachala [To the problem of implementation of the constitutional settlement-territorial principle of organization of local self-government. In defence of settlement option]. Mestnoe pravo, no.4, pp.25–52. (In Russian).
Bhattacharyya H. (2021) Federalism in Asia: India, Pakistan, Malaysia, Nepal and Myanmar, 2nd ed., Abingdon; New York: Routledge.
Burgi M. (2009) Federal Republic of Germany. In: Steytler N., Kincaid J. (eds.) A Global Dialogue on Federalism. Vol.6: Local Government and Metropolitan Regions in Federal Systems, Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press, pp.136–165.
De Queiroz Ribeiro L.C., Braule Pinto S.G. (2009) Brazil. In: Steytler N., Kincaid J. (eds.) A Global Dialogue on Federalism. Vol.6: Local Government and Metropolitan Regions in Federal Systems, Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press, pp.75–105.
De Souza C.M. (2016) Local Governments in Brazil: Are They the Hub of the Brazilian “Welfare State”? In: Sadioglu U., Dede K. (eds.) Comparative Studies and Regionally-Focused Cases Examining Local Governments, Hershey, PA: Information Science Reference.
De Tocqueville A. (1992) Demokratiya v Amerike [Democracy in America], V.P.Oleynik et al. (transl.), Moscow: Progress. (In Russian).
DeSouza P.R. (2003) The Struggle for Local Government: Indian Democracy’s New Phase. Publius: The Journal of Federalism, vol.33, no.4, pp.99–118.
Erk J. (2008) Explaining Federalism: State, Society and Congruence in Austria, Belgium, Canada, Germany and Switzerland, Abingdon; New York: Routledge.
Ferrari S. (2003) Constituição Estadual e Federação, Rio de Janeiro: Lumen Juris.
Galadima H. (2009) Federal Republic of Nigeria. In: Steytler N., Kincaid J. (eds.) A Global Dialogue on Federalism. Vol.6: Local Government and Metropolitan Regions in Federal Systems, Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press, pp.234–266.
Graizbord B. (2009) United Mexican States. In: Steytler N., Kincaid J. (eds.) A Global Dialogue on Federalism. Vol.6: Local Government and Metropolitan Regions in Federal Systems, Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press, pp.200–233.
Gritsenko E.V. (2001) Mestnoe samoupravlenie v sisteme publichnogo upravleniya federativnogo gosudarstva: Znachenie opyta FRG dlya Rossii [Local self-government in the system of public administration of a federal state. Significance of the FRG experience for Russia], Irkutsk: Izdatel'stvo Irkutskoy gosudarstvennoy ekonomicheskoy akademii. (In Russian).
Gritsenko E. (2014) V poiskakh utrachennykh idealov: rossiyskaya munitsipal'naya reforma i opyt Germanii [Local self-government in Russia and Germany: similarities and differences between models]. Sravnitel'noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie, vol.23, no.6, pp.17–43. (In Russian).
Gritsenko E.V. (2025) Mestnoe samoupravlenie: mezhdu detsentralizatsiey i retsentralizatsiey [Local self-government: between decentralization and re-centralization]. In: Medushevsky A.N. (ed.) Konstitutsiya Rossii posle reformy 2020 goda: problemnyy kommentariy [The Constitution of Russia after the 2020 reform: Legal and political commentary], Moscow: Tsentr konstitutsionnykh issledovaniy, pp.136–184. (In Russian).
Kiefer A., Schausberger F. (2009) Republic of Austria. In: Steytler N., Kincaid J. (eds.) A Global Dialogue on Federalism. Vol.6: Local Government and Metropolitan Regions in Federal Systems, Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press, pp.37–74.
Korkunov N.M. (1909) Russkoe gosudarstvennoe pravo. Tom II. Chast' osobennaya [Russian state law. Vol.II. The special part], 6th ed., Saint Petersburg: Tipografiya M.M.Stasyulevicha. (In Russian).
Korol'kov V.V. (2024) Federativnye otnosheniya v predmete konstitutsionnogo prava: Dis. … kand. yurid. nauk [Federal relations in the subject of constitutional law: Cand. in law sci. diss.], Moscow. (In Russian).
Kovaleva T.K. (2017) Sovremennye tendentsii razvitiya mestnogo samoupravleniya v SShA: poisk optimal'nykh modeley organizatsii i deyatel'nosti mestnykh vlastey [Recent trends in local government development in the USA: finding local authorities’ optimal organizational and functional models]. Ekonomika: vchera, segodnya, zavtra, no.10A, pp.50–58. (In Russian).
Malaviya H.D. (1956) Village Panchayats in India, New Delhi: All India Congress Committee, Economic and Political Research Department.
Mathew J., Hooja R. (2009) Republic of India. In: Steytler N., Kincaid J. (eds.) A Global Dialogue on Federalism. Vol.6: Local Government and Metropolitan Regions in Federal Systems, Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press, pp.166–199.
Mendoza Ruiz J. (2009) El Principio de Subsidiariedad en la Evaluación del Federalismo Mexicano: Finanzas Públicas, Políticas Públicas y Organización Social: Tesis Doctoral, Programa en Ciencias Políticas y Sociales, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México.
Mushieka H. (2018) Federalism and Poverty Reduction in Nigeria and Sudan: The Politics of Local, State and Federal Relations. International Journal of Business and Management Invention, vol.7, no.3. Available at: https://journals.indexcopernicus.com/api/file/viewByFileId/395265 (accessed: 08.03.2025).
Okafor S.O. (1981) Indirect Rule: The Development of Central Legislature in Nigeria, Lagos: Nelson Africa.
Onapajo H., Fatai A. (2021) A Stagnant or Retrogressive Democracy? Elections and Democracy in Nigeria, 1999–2019. In: Tella O. (ed.) A Sleeping Giant? Nigeria’s Domestic and International Politics in the Twenty-First Century, Cham: Springer, pp.3–16.
Pagano M.A. (2009) United States of America. In: Steytler N., Kincaid J. (eds.) A Global Dialogue on Federalism. Vol.6: Local Government and Metropolitan Regions in Federal Systems, Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press, pp.363–392.
Pernthaler P., Gamper A. (2005) Local Government in Austria. In: Steytler N. (ed.) The Place and Role of Local Government in Federal Systems, Johannesburg: Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung.
Peters H. (1949) Lehrbuch der Verwaltung, Berlin: Springer.
Rumyantsev O.G. (ed.) (2007) Iz istorii sozdaniya Konstitutsii Rossiyskoy Federatsii. Konstitutsionnaya komissiya: stenogrammy, materialy, dokumenty (1990–1993 gg.). Tom 1: 1990 god [From the history of the creation of the Constitution of the Russian Federation. Constitutional Commission: transcripts, materials, documents (1990–1993). Vol.1: 1990], in 6 vols., Moscow: Wolters Kluwer. (In Russian).
Sansom G. (2009) Commonwealth of Australia. In: Steytler N., Kincaid J. (eds.) A Global Dialogue on Federalism. Vol.6: Local Government and Metropolitan Regions in Federal Systems, Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press, pp.7–36.
Steytler N. (2009) Introduction. In: Steytler N., Kincaid J. (eds.) A Global Dialogue on Federalism. Vol.6: Local Government and Metropolitan Regions in Federal Systems, Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press, pp.3–6.
Tavares A.R. (2017) Curso de Direito Constitucional, 15th ed., São Paulo: Saraiva.
Tullock G. (1993) Novyy federalist [The new federalist], Moscow: Fond “Za ekonomicheskuyu gramotnost'”. (In Russian).
Wollmann H. (2024) Local Government and Governance in Germany: Challenges, Responses and Perspectives, Cham: Springer.