Available in Russian
Author: Anna Śledzińska-Simon
DOI: 10.21128/1812-7126-2025-2-103-124
Keywords: constitutional courts; access to justice; gender equality; substantive equality; women’s rights; Central and Eastern Europe
This article examines the phenomenon of constitutional injustice through the lens of the absence of a substantive gender equality perspective in constitutional courts, focusing on Central and Eastern European (CEE) countries. While rooted in regional analysis, the discussion addresses a broader global issue: the structural barriers women face in accessing constitutional justice. These include formal, doctrinal, and interpretative constraints that inhibit courts from engaging meaningfully with gender-based claims. The article traces this problem to the socialist-era conception of gender equality, which emphasized formal rights and protective measures while maintaining traditional gender roles. This legacy entrenched a culture of legal formalism and positivism that continues to dominate constitutional interpretation in the region, impeding the adoption of more inclusive and socially responsive approaches. The article identifies three dimensions of constitutional gender injustice: limited access to constitutional courts, doctrinal limitations in reviewing equality claims, and judicial avoidance in balancing competing rights and values. To address these challenges, the article tests Sandra Fredman’s model of substantive equality, comprising disadvantage, recognition, voice and participation, and accommodation of difference, against the actual practices of constitutional courts in the region. It argues that applying this model can guide courts toward more inclusive jurisprudence and help embed substantive gender equality into constitutional review.
About the author: Anna Śledzińska-Simon – Dr. hab., Professor, Faculty of Law, Administration and Economics, University of Wrocław, Wrocław, Poland .
Citation:
Śledzińska-Simon A. (2025) Konstitutsionnaya gendernaya spravedlivost’ v Tsentral'noy i Vostochnoy Evrope? Razmyshleniya na temu realizatsii printsipa soderzhatel'nogo ravenstva konstitutsionnymi sudami [Constitutional gender justice in Central and Eastern Europe? Notes on the implementation of the principle of substantive equality by constitutional courts]. Sravnitel'noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie, vol.34, no.2, pp.??–124. (In Russian).
References
Ackerman B. (2007) The Living Constitution. Harvard Law Review, vol.120, no.7, pp.1737–1812.
Antos M. (2012) Constitutional Complaint and Its Limits in the Czech Republic. Annales Universitatis Scientiarum Budapestinensis de Rolando Eötvös. Nominatae — Sectio Iuridica, vol.53, pp.119–132.
Balkin J.M. (2009) Framework Originalism and the Living Constitution. Northwestern University Law Review, vol.103, no.2, pp.549–614.
Balogh L., Drinóczi T. (2025) Women, Sexual Orientation, Gender Identity, and Constitutional Developments in Hungary. International Journal of Constitutional Law, vol.23. (Forthcoming).
Branta A. (2010) Peculiarities of Functioning and Problems of Improvement of Capability of Institution of an Individual Complaint in the Republic of Latvia. Available at: https://www.satv.tiesa.gov.lv/en/runas-un-raksti/peculiarities-of-functioning-and-problems-of-improvement-of-capability-of-institution-of-an-individual-complaint-in-the-republic-of-latvia/ (accessed: 14.06.2025).
Brewer-Carías A.R. (2012) Constitutional Courts as Positive Legislators. In: Brown K.B., Snyder D.V. (eds.) General Reports of the XVIIIth Congress of the International Academy of Comparative Law, Springer: Dordrecht, pp.549–570.
Brodeală E. (2019) Gender Discrimination in Romania through the Case Law of the ECtHR: Searching for the Roots of the Systemic Failure to Protect Women’s Rights in Romania. In: Havelková B., Möschel M. (eds.) Anti-Discrimination Law in Civil Law Jurisdictions, New York: Oxford University Press, pp.214–232.
Brodeală E. (2025) Gender Roles and the Family under Romania’s Post-Socialist Constitution: Between Progress and Restraint. International Journal of Constitutional Law, vol.23. (Forthcoming).
Castillo-Ortiz P. (2019) The Illiberal Abuse of Constitutional Courts in Europe. European Constitutional Law Review, vol.15, no.1, pp.48–72.
Cserne P. (2015) Formalism in Judicial Reasoning: Is Central and Eastern Europe a Special Case? In: Bobek M. (ed.) Central European Judges Under the European Influence: The Transformative Power of the EU Revisited, Oxford: Hart.
Csink L., Petrétei J., Tilk P. (2011) Hungary: Constitutional Court as Positive Legislator. In: Brewer-Carías A.R. (ed.) Constitutional Courts as Positive Legislators: A Comparative Law Study, New York: Cambridge University Press, pp.575–585.
Daneliene I. (2021) Individual Access to Constitutional Justice in Lithuania: The Potential within the Newly Established Model of The Individual Constitutional Complaint. Revista de Derecho Político, no.111, pp.281–312.
De Vido S. (2017) States’ Positive Obligations to Eradicate Domestic Violence: The Politics of Relevance in the Interpretation of the European Convention on Human Rights. ESIL Reflections, vol.6, no.6. Available at: https://esil-sedi.eu/post_name-119/ (accessed: 14.06.2025).
Dębska H. (2014) Płeć i władza. Kobiety w Trybunale Konstytucyjnym [Gender and power. Women in the Constitutional Tribunal]. Studia Podlaskie, no.22, pp.91–111.
Dębska H. (2015) Władza, symbol, prawo. Społeczne tworzenie Trybunału Konstytucyjnego [Power, symbol, law. The social creation of the Constitutional Tribunal], Warsaw: Sejmowe.
Dębska H. (2024) Prawo-mocność. Teoria społeczna Pierre’a Bourdieu a przestrzenie prawa [Law-power. Pierre Bourdieu’s social theory and spaces of law], Warsaw: Wolters Kluwer.
Ely J.H. (1980) Democracy and Distrust: A Theory of Judicial Review, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Ernits M. (2024) Constitutional Review in Estonia — a Model for 30 Years? East-West Studies, no.14. Available at: http://publications.tlu.ee/index.php/eastwest/article/view/1349 (accessed: 14.06.2025).
Ernits M., Miliuvienė J., Pleps J., Sinkevičius V. (2022) Models of Constitutional Adjudication in The Baltic States. International Social Science Journal, vol.72, no.246, pp.1217–1235.
Florczak-Wątor M. (2018) Konstytucja jako źródło obowiązków państwa w stosunku do obywatela [The Constitution as the source of the state’s obligations towards its citizens]. Ruch Prawniczy, Ekonomiczny i Socjologiczny, vol.80, no.1, pp.119–131.
Florczak-Wątor M. (ed.) (2020) Judicial Law-Making in European Constitutional Courts, Abingdon; New York: Routledge.
Fredman S. (2016) Substantive Equality Revisited. International Journal of Constitutional Law, vol.14, no.3, pp.712–738.
Gajda A. (2013) Kierunki rozwoju instytucji Rzecznika Praw Obywatelskich w Polsce [Directions for the development of the Ombudsman institution in Poland], Warsaw: Sejmowe.
Galligan Y., Clavero S., Calloni M. (2008) Gender Politics and Democracy in Post-Socialist Europe, Farmington Hills, MI: Barbara Budrich.
Gárdos-Orosz F. (2012) The Hungarian Constitutional Court in Transition — from Actio Popularis to Constitutional Complaint. Acta Juridica Hungarica, vol.53, no.4, pp.302–315.
Gerards J.H. (2004) Intensity of Judicial Review in Equal Treatment Cases. Netherlands International Law Review, vol.51, no.2, pp.135–183.
Glavina M. (2024) From a Potentially Powerful to a Polarised Court: The Emergence of Dissenting Opinions on the Croatian Constitutional Court. European Politics and Society, vol.25, no.3, pp.518–536.
Gruev I. (2025) Constitutionalizing Gender: Deterrence Instead of Equality. International Journal of Constitutional Law, vol.23. (Forthcoming).
Halmai G. (2019) Dismantling Constitutional Review in Hungary. Rivista di Diritti Comparati, no.1, pp.31–47.
Havelková B. (2016) Resistance to Anti-Discrimination Law in Central and Eastern Europe — a Post-Communist Legacy? German Law Journal, vol.17, no.4, pp.627–656.
Havelková B. (2017) Gender Equality in Law: Uncovering the Legacies of Czech State Socialism, Oxford: Hart.
Havelková B. (2019) The Pre-Eminence of the General Principle of Equality over Specific Prohibition of Discrimination on Suspect Grounds in Czechia. In: Havelková B., Möschel M. (eds.) Anti-Discrimination Law in Civil Law Jurisdictions, New York: Oxford University Press, pp.76–93.
Havelková B. (2020) The Struggle for Social Constructivism in Postsocialist Central and Eastern Europe. International Journal of Constitutional Law, vol.18, no.2, pp.434–440.
Havelková B., Boková T., Berdisová L. (2025) The Non-Constitutionalization and Avoidant Constitutionalization of Gender in Czechia and Slovakia. International Journal of Constitutional Law, vol.23. (Forthcoming).
Henn E.V. (2019) International Human Rights Law and Structural Discrimination: The Example of Violence against Women, Berlin: Springer.
Horvat Vuković A., Samobor A. (2025) Constitutional Construction of Reproductive Rights and Family in Croatia and Slovenia. International Journal of Constitutional Law, vol.23. (Forthcoming).
Jakab A., Fröhlich J. (2017) The Constitutional Court of Hungary. In: Jakab A., Dyevre A., Itzcovich G. (eds.) Comparative Constitutional Reasoning, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp.394–437.
Kavanagh A. (2003) The Idea of a Living Constitution. Canadian Journal of Law & Jurisprudence, vol.16, no.1, pp.55–89.
Kay R. (ed.) (2007) Gender, Equality and Difference During and After State Socialism, London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Kelemen K. (2014) Access to Constitutional Justice in the New Hungarian Constitutional Framework: Life After the Actio Popularis? In: Geisler A., Hein M., Hummel S. (eds.) Law, Politics, and the Constitution: New Perspectives from Legal and Political Theory, Frankfurt am Main: Peter Lang, pp.63–78.
Kelsen H. (1989) Pure Theory of Law, Gloucester, MA: Peter Smith.
Kłopocka-Jasińska M. (2020) Skarga konstytucyjna na orzeczenie sądu: Model możliwy do zastosowania w Polsce [Constitutional complaint against a court ruling. A model applicable in Poland], Warsaw: Wolters Kluwer Polska.
Kolarova R. (1993) A Self-Restricting Court. Eastern European Constitutional Review, vol.2, no.2, pp.48–51.
Kosař D., Šipulová K. (2023) Comparative Court-Packing. International Journal of Constitutional Law, vol.21, no.1, pp.80–126.
Kovács K., Tóth G.A. (2023) Constitutional Review as a Democratic Instrument. Review of Central and East European Law, vol.48, no.3/4, pp.473–489.
Kühn Z. (2011) Czech Republic: Czech Constitutional Court as Positive Legislator? In: Brewer-Carías A.R. (ed.) Constitutional Courts as Positive Legislators: A Comparative Law Study, New York: Cambridge University Press, pp.445–470.
Kühn Z. (2011) The Judiciary in Central and Eastern Europe: Mechanical Jurisprudence in Transformation? Leiden: Martinus Nijhoff.
Kühn Z. (2021) The Rise and Fall of Central Eastern European Constitutional Courts. In: Urbanik J., Bodnar A. (eds.) Περιμένοντας τους Bαρβάρους: Law in a Time of Constitutional Crisis: Studies Offered to Mirosław Wyrzykowski, Warsaw: C.H.Beck, pp.373–386.
Łabno A. (2012) Skarga konstytucyjna jako środek ochrony praw człowieka. Przyczynek do dyskusji [Constitutional complaints as a means of protecting human rights. A contribution to the discussion]. Przegląd Prawa Konstytucyjnego, no.4, pp.39–60.
Massey G., Hahn K., Sekulić D. (1995) Women, Men, and the “Second Shift” in Socialist Yugoslavia. Gender & Society, vol.9, no.3, pp.359–379.
Massino J., Penn S. (2009) Introduction: Gender Politics and Everyday Life in State Socialist Eastern and Central Europe. In: Massino J., Penn S. (eds.) Gender Politics and Everyday Life in State Socialist Eastern and Central Europe, New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Pascall G., Kwak A. (2010) Gender Regimes in Transition: Gender Equality in CEE Countries? In: Klenner C., Leiber S. (eds.) Welfare States and Gender Inequality in Central and Eastern Europe: Continuity and Post-Socialist Transformation in the EU Member States, Bristol: European Trade Union Institute, pp.117–150.
Pócza K. (2019) Constitutional Politics and the Judiciary: Decision-Making in Central and Eastern Europe, Abingdon; New York: Routledge.
Potrzeszcz J. (2003) Sprawiedliwość społeczna w skardze konstytucyjnej [Social justice in constitutional complaints]. Roczniki Nauk Prawnych, vol.13, no.1, pp.17–30.
Przywora B. (2020) Czy art.32 Konstytucji RP (zasada równości) może stanowić samodzielny wzorzec kontroli w sprawach inicjowanych skargą konstytucyjną? Przyczynek do dyskusji [Can article 32 of the Polish Constitution (the principle of equality) constitute an independent standard of review in cases initiated by a constitutional complaint? A contribution to the discussion]. Przegląd Prawa Publicznego, no.7–8, pp.166–181.
Radziewicz P. (2013) Kontrola konstytucyjności zaniechań ustawodawczych przez Trybunał Konstytucyjny [Constitutional review of legislative omissions by the Constitutional Tribunal]. Państwo i Prawo, no.9, pp.3–17.
Rosenberg G.D. (2023) The Hollow Hope: Can Courts Bring About Social Change? Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
Sabján N., Meteňkanyč O.M. (2024) The Recent Transgender Court Decision in Czechia: Two Steps Forward, One Step Back (A Commentary on Case Pl. ÚS 52/23). Bratislava Law Review, vol.8, no.2, pp.243–264.
Sadurski W. (2014) Rights Before Courts: A Study of Constitutional Courts in Postcommunist States of Central and Eastern Europe, Dordrecht: Springer.
Schwartz H. (2000) The Struggle for Constitutional Justice in Post-Communist Europe, Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
Selejan-Gutan B. (2016) The Constitution of Romania: A Contextual Analysis, Oxford: Hart.
Shaffer H.G. (2013) Women in the Two Germanies: A Comparative Study of a Socialist and a Non-Socialist Society, New York: Pergamon Press.
Šimáčková K., Špondrová P., Havelková B. (2020) Mužské právo. Jsou právní pravidla neutrální? [Male law. Are legal rules neutral?], Prague: Wolters Kluwer.
Slavova K., Stoilova R. (2024) Intersectionality: Perspectives from Central and Eastern Europe. In: Davis K., Lutz H. (eds.) The Routledge International Handbook of Intersectionality Studies, Abingdon; New York: Routledge, pp.28–41.
Śledzińska-Simon A., Wójcik A. (2024) Taking Women’s Rights Seriously: Women’s Struggle for a New “Social Contract” in Poland. Pravni zapisi, vol.15, no.1, pp.20–56.
Smekal H., Benák J., Vyhnánek L. (2021) Through Selective Activism Towards Greater Resilience: The Czech Constitutional Court’s Interventions into High Politics in the Age of Populism. International Journal of Human Rights, vol.26, no.7, pp.1230–1251.
Sólyom L. (2003) The Role of Constitutional Courts in the Transition to Democracy: With Special Reference to Hungary. International Sociology, vol.18, no.1, pp.133–161.
Stambulski M. (2024) Populist Jurisprudence? Examining Selected Case Law of the Polish Constitutional Court After 2016. Hague Journal on the Rule of Law, vol.16, no.2, pp.245–262.
Strauss D.A. (2010) The Living Constitution, New York: Oxford University Press.
Sulikowski A. (2024) The Polish Constitutional Court in the Grip of Neo-liberalism. In: Mańko R., Sulikowski A., Tacik P., Cercel C. (eds.) Law, Populism, and the Political in Central and Eastern Europe, Abingdon; New York: Birkbeck Law Press, pp.72–89.
Suteu S. (2024) Beyond Formal Conceptions of Judicial Leadership: Women on the Bench, Judicial Influence, and Judge Rapporteurs on the Romanian Constitutional Court. In: Delaney E., Dixon R. (eds.) Constitutional Heroines and Feminist Judicial Leadership, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
Tarasek M. (2014) Trybunał Konstytucyjny a kontrola zaniechań legislacyjnych [The Constitutional Tribunal and the review of legislative omissions]. Przegląd Prawa Konstytucyjnego, vol.17, no.1, pp.259–276.
Timmer A. (2013) A Quiet Revolution: Vulnerability in the European Court of Human Rights. In: Fineman M.A., Grear A. (eds.) Vulnerability: Reflections on a New Ethical Foundation for Law and Politics, Farnham: Ashgate, pp.147–170.
Vikarská Z., Ouředníčková S. (2022) Evasive, Insensitive, Ignorant, and Political: The Recent Czech Transgender Case. Verfassungsblog, 6 April. Available at: https://verfassungsblog.de/evasive-insensitive-ignorant-and-political/ (accessed: 14.06.2025).
Wieruszewski R. (1975) Równość kobiet i mężczyzn w Polskiej Republice Ludowej [Equality between women and men in the Polish People’s Republic], Poznań: Wydawnictwo Poznańskie.