Available in Russian
Authors: Irina Dudko, Olga Kryazhkova
DOI: 10.21128/1812-7126-2025-3-4-25
Keywords: protection of rights and freedoms by means of constitutional justice; indirect individual access to constitutional justice; court requests to the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation; complaints of the Prosecutor General to the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation; complaints of ombudspersons to the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation; complaints of all-Russian organizations to the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation
The article examines the institution of indirect access of citizens and organizations to constitutional justice in Russia, which is less fully covered in domestic legal scholarship compared to direct access — complaints from individuals about the violation of their constitutional rights and freedoms. The authors examine this institution in historical and legal dynamics, starting with the activities of Committee for Constitutional Supervision of the USSR and the Constitutional Court of the RSFSR, when indirect access was declarative in nature, and ending with the current state, enshrined in the current editions of the Constitution of the Russian Federation and the Federal Constitutional Law “On the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation”. The main attention is paid to the analysis of all forms of indirect access: court requests for constitutionality of regulations to be applied in specific cases, complaints from the Prosecutor General, federal and regional human rights commissioners, specialized ombudspersons, as well as all-Russian organizations that can represent the interests of individuals. Having studied the legislation and practice of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation in considering appeals from these bodies and officials, the authors conclude that the effectiveness of the relevant mechanisms is uneven compared to each other. Court requests for specific cases can be considered the most effective method of indirect access, which is confirmed by their frequency and law enforcement significance. Complaints from the federal ombudspersons have demonstrated a certain potential, but their use depends on the activity of a specific official. At the same time, the institution of complaints from the Prosecutor General turned out to be practically unclaimed, and new mechanisms — appeals from regional and specialized ombudspersons, as well as all-Russian organizations — are still in the process of formation. The authors emphasize the discrepancy between constitutional and legal norms and sectoral legislation, which complicates the full functioning of indirect access. The article proposes either reforming or abolishing ineffective institutions, as well as legal strengthening of new mechanisms in order to ensure real protection of citizens’ rights by means of constitutional justice.
About the authors: Irina Dudko – Candidate of Sciences (Ph.D.) in Law, Associate Professor, Russian State University of Justice, Moscow, Russia; Olga Kryazhkova – Candidate of Sciences (Ph.D.) in Law, Associate Professor, Russian State University of Justice, Moscow, Russia.
Citation:
Dudko I., Kryazhkova O. (2025) Kosvennyy dostup grazhdan k konstitutsionnomu pravosudiyu v Rossii [Indirect individual access to constitutional justice in Russia]. Sravnitel'noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie, vol.34, no.3, pp.4–25. (In Russian).
References
Arutyunyan G.G. (1997) Konstitutsionnyy kontrol': kharakter funktsionirovaniya i razvitiya sistemy: monografiya [Constitutional control: the nature of the functioning and development of the system: monograph], Moscow. (In Russian).
Brezhnev O.V. (2013) Prokuror kak uchastnik konstitutsionnogo sudoproizvodstva: problemy, tendentsii, perspektivy [Prosecutor as a participant in constitutional proceedings: problems, trends, prospects]. Konstitutsionnoe i munitsipal'noe pravo, no.5, pp.49–55. (In Russian).
Filatov S.A., Chernomyrdin V.S., Shakhray S.M. et al. (eds.) (1996) Konstitutsionnoe soveshchanie. Stenogrammy. Materialy. Dokumenty. T.18: 8 sentyabrya — 21 oktyabrya 1993 g. [Constitutional Conference. Transcripts. Materials. Documents. Vol.18: September 8 — October 21, 1993], Moscow: Yuridicheskaya literatura. (In Russian).
Gadzhiev G.A. (ed.) (2012) Kommentariy k Federal'nomu konstitutsionnomu zakonu “O Konstitutsionnom Sude Rossiyskoy Federatsii” (postateynyy) [Commentary on the federal constitutional law “On the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation” (article by article)], Moscow: Norma; Infra-M. (In Russian).
Herbst С. (2015) Konstitutsionnaya zhaloba v Avstrii [The constitutional complaint in Austria]. Zhurnal Konstitutsionnogo pravosudiya, no.5, pp.32–34. (In Russian).
Kelsen H. (2006) Sudebnaya garantiya Konstitutsii (konstitutsionnaya yustitsiya) [Judicial guarantee of the Constitution (constitutional justice)]. Pravo i politika, no.9, pp.5–18. (In Russian).
Kelsen H. (2012) Sudebnyy kontrol' zakonodatel'stva: sravnitel'noe issledovanie avstriyskoy i amerikanskoy konstitutsiy [Judicial review of legislation: a comparative study of the Austrian and American сonstitutions]. Pravovedenie, no.2, pp.190–202. (In Russian).
Kravets I.A. (2003) Konstitutsionnaya zhaloba: traditsii i novatsii v mekhanizme garantiy prav i svobod lichnosti [Constitutional complaint: traditions and innovations in the mechanism of guarantees of individual rights and freedoms]. Zhurnal rossiyskogo prava, no.8, pp.19–29. (In Russian).
Kryazhkov V.A., Mityukov M.A. (2022) Tom 9: Istoriya konstitutsionnogo pravosudiya v Rossii [Vol.9: The history of constitutional justice in Russia]. In: Istoriya suda i pravosudiya v Rossii [The history of the court and justice in Russia], in 9 vols., Moscow: Norma. (In Russian).
Mityukov M.A. (ed.) (2011) Bibliografiya po konstitutsionnomu pravosudiyu [Bibliography on constitutional justice], 2nd ed., Moscow: Knorus. (In Russian).
Mityukov M.A. (ed.) (2018) Konstitutsionnoe pravosudie. Sistematizirovannyy bibliograficheskiy ukazatel' (2011–2016) [Constitutional justice. Systematized bibliographic index (2011–2016)], Moscow: Prospekt. (In Russian).
Morshchakova T. (2025) Teoriya i yurisprudentsiya Federal'nogo konstitutsionnogo suda Germanii: u istokov rossiyskogo sudebnogo konstitutsionnogo kontrolya [Theory and jurisprudence of the German Federal Constitutional Court: at the origins of the Russian judicial constitutional review]. Sravnitel'noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie, vol.34, no.2, pp.49–76. (In Russian).
Vinokurov A.Yu. (2021) Popravki k Konstitutsii Rossiyskoy Federatsii v kontekste zakrepleniya statusnykh polozheniy o prokurature [Amendments to the Constitution of the Russian Federation within the framework of consolidation of the status provisions on the Prosecutor’s office]. Konstitutsionnoe i munitsipal'noe pravo, no.4, pp.31–34. (In Russian).